OG 10-151 请教NN

hedyqian

151. Generally scientists enter their field with the goal of doing important new research and accept as their colleagues those with similar motivation. Therefore, when any scientist wins renown as an expounder of science to general audiences, most other scientists conclude that this popularizer should no longer be regarded as a true colleague.

            

The explanation offered above for the low esteem in which scientific popularizers are held by research scientists assumes that

(A) serious scientific research is not a solitary activity, but relies on active cooperation among a group of colleagues

(B) research scientists tend not to regard as colleagues those scientists whose renown they envy

(C) a scientist can become a famous popularizer without having completed any important research

(D) research scientists believe that those who are well known as popularizers of science are not motivated to do important new research

(E) no important new research can be accessible to or accurately assessed by those who are not themselves scientists D
            

答案选D基本上明白了，可是E为什么不对呢？

如果将E取非，重要的新研究能够被不是科学较的人接受，那么因为普及科学而出名的科学家，不是就可以做重要的新研究了吗，那样因为普及科学而出名的科学家不就可以被regard as true colleagues了吗？  这样E取非后，对题目削弱了啊！

答案选D基本上明白了，可是E为什么不对呢？

如果将E取非，重要的新研究能够被不是科学较的人接受，那么因为普及科学而出名的科学家，不是就可以做重要的新研究了吗，那样因为普及科学而出名的科学家不就可以被regard as true colleagues了吗？  这样E取非后，对题目削弱了啊！

gmat_cxl

E is irrelevant to the provided statement. the converted meaning is that only scientists can access/assess the important new research.

tamama

以下是引用hedyqian在2008-7-9 22:47:00的发言：

答案选D基本上明白了，可是E为什么不对呢？

如果将E取非，重要的新研究能够被不是科学较的人接受，那么因为普及科学而出名的科学家，不是就可以做重要的新研究了吗，那样因为普及科学而出名的科学家不就可以被regard as true colleagues了吗？  这样E取非后，对题目削弱了啊！

LZ的逻辑很奇怪啊，为什么新研究可以被其他人接触到，就能推出著名的科学家就可以做新研究了呢？

E选项是无关选项。