GWD5-28 求助阿~~

mayautumn86

如下，做的时候就看了半天选不出，订正的时候还是……请教阿嗄阿~~~

Which of the following most logically completes the argument below?

 

According to promotional material published by the city of Springfield, more tourists stay in hotels in Springfield than stay in the neighboring city of Harristown.  A brochure from the largest hotel in Harristown claims that more tourists stay in that hotel than stay in the Royal Arms Hotel in Springfield.  If both of these sources are accurate, however, the county’s “Report on Tourism” must be in error in indicating that _______.

 

1. more tourists stay in hotel accommodations in Harristown than stay in the Royal Arms Hotel
2. the Royal Arms Hotel is the only hotel in Springfield
3. there are several hotels in Harristown that are larger than the Royal Arms Hotel
4. some of the tourists who have stayed in hotels in Harristown have also stayed in the Royal Arms Hotel
5. some hotels in Harristown have fewer tourist guests each year than the Royal Arms Hotel has

   Answer: B

pharmacystar

must be in error ,选B

S比H的总旅客量多

H的一家宾馆比S的一家宾馆人数多

B S只有R一家宾馆,那么应该推出 H比s的总旅客量多

与题干矛盾

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-3-27 10:41:32编辑过]

graceguo98

请教

“S比H的总旅客量多

H的一家宾馆比S的一家宾馆人数多”

原文说这两个信息都是正确的，如果RA是S唯一的宾馆，

那么第一个叙述“S比H的总旅客量多”就不正确了丫，是否与原文“these souraces are accurate”相矛盾了呢？

对问题可否理解为：“如果这些信息都是正确的，然而，这个县的旅游报告一定是在错误指示——————把H镇的hotel 的一些旅游者人数与S镇的RA一家hotel 比较，结果少，所以推出H的旅客少于S的”

所以我选择E，为什么错呢？

绕晕了。

谢谢

ruimuni

题目中给出的是：

城市S：S hotel 的游客比城市H hotel 的游客多

brochure：在H最大的hotel的游客比S城市中R hotel的游客多

根据B所说的内容可以推出游客数S=R，既然H城市最大hotel的游客数都大于S城市的游客数，那么题目中给出的第一句话S>H就不成立了，我是这么理解的