请教GWD17-Q9 （没有讨论过）

sunandmoon

Press Secretary:  Our critics claim that the President’s recent highway project cancellations demonstrate a vindictive desire to punish legislative districts controlled by opposition parties.  They offer as evidence the fact that 90 percent of the projects canceled were in such districts.  But all of the canceled projects had been identified as wasteful in a report written by respected nonpartisan auditors.  So the President’s choice was clearly motivated by sound budgetary policy, not partisan politics.

 

Which of the following is an assumption on which the press secretary’s argument depends?

 

1. Canceling highway projects was not the only way for the President to punish legislative districts controlled by opposition parties.

2. The scheduled highway projects identified as wasteful in the report were not mostly projects in districts controlled by the President’s party.

3. The number of projects canceled was a significant proportion of all the highway projects that were to be undertaken by the government in the near future.

4. The highway projects canceled in districts controlled by the President’s party were not generally more expensive than the projects canceled in districts controlled by opposition parties.

5. Reports by nonpartisan auditors are not generally regarded by the opposition parties as a source of objective assessments of government projects.

答案是B，我选了D。据说是取非，但我想不通。

cx1205

d应该不对,至少我觉得d是无关的,原文没提到是贵还是便宜

原文意思,因为在反对党执政的地区90%被拒绝,所以有人说这次高速被拒绝是在惩罚反对党,但作者认为那些被拒绝的而且被坚定为垃圾的计划是由无党派人事审计的,所以这个高速的计划是从财政预算出发,不过对反对党的惩罚 注意红字,红字才是最终结论

把b取非.那些被鉴定为垃圾但却被拿到执行日程上来计划,在president's party管辖的地方,占了很大部分(这明显反驳了结论)

superHI

我选E

总统那边的意思是报告是非党派人士搞出来的,不关我们执政党的事情.不是我们想故意拆你们反对党的台.

问题是总统那边这么说,根据是什么?肯定是不根据B吧.

总统那边逻辑的关键是,这个报告不是我们搞出来的,是武当派那帮爷爷搞的,要认定这个报告的客观性.而不是说谁的地盘被废的多,谁的被废的少吧.

maurise

选B 如果名单上执政党控制地区的项目更多而百分之九十被取消的是反对党控制地区的项目 则说明总统对自己地区的项目包庇了即惩罚对方 发言人应该假设的是这种情况不存在

yzhao26

up

buda

这道题好别扭啊怎么之前没有人讨论呢？

是不是这里面把浪费项目分为了两种：canceled projects和scheduled  projects？

其中canceled projects中反对党辖区占90%，有人以这个为理由说这是政治惩罚

如果B选项取非说scheduled  projects大多数都是执政党辖区的，更加说明执政党偏袒自己项目取消反对党的项目，因此反驳结论说是预算因故。

还是很晕乎，有没有人再来讲讲？

oliverchenxu

被认定为wasteful的项目中有被cancelled的和没被cancelled(scheduled)的
所以B是对的

rockmax

以下是引用superHI在2008-4-24 10:45:00的发言：

我选E

总统那边的意思是报告是非党派人士搞出来的,不关我们执政党的事情.不是我们想故意拆你们反对党的台.

问题是总统那边这么说,根据是什么?肯定是不根据B吧.

总统那边逻辑的关键是,这个报告不是我们搞出来的,是武当派那帮爷爷搞的,要认定这个报告的客观性.而不是说谁的地盘被废的多,谁的被废的少吧.

E 取非不削弱,,  仔细看看

boum

up