逻辑题请教

fyj2004

q

Grazing livestock on public land in the western United States is not causing widespread environmental damage in the region, since if it were, the condition of that land would not be improving. However, only 14 percent of public land in the area today is considered to have inadequate vegetation cover and, therefore, to be in poor condition, while in the 1930's, 36 percent had inadequate vegetation cover.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument above?

A) In the western United States, private land is typically more lush than public land, and cattle that graze on prive land can be fattened more quickly.

B) Since the 1930's, recreational users of public land in the western United States have caused more environmental damage than have the cattle grazing there.

C) During the 1930's, an unusually destructive dtrought prevailed thoughout the region where most public lands in the western United States are located.

D) Ranchers who use public land in the western United States pay only a fraction of what is paid by those who lease comparable private land for grazing.

E) The amount of land purchased by the United States government since the 1930's is relatively insignificant.

请各位指教，这道题目的结论我都看不出是什么

Lily0515

Grazing livestock
            is not causing widespread environmental damage in the region,
        若是Grazing livestock则the condition of that land would not be improving.

However, 1930有36%inadequate vegetation cover.;现在only 14 percent of public land is considered to have inadequate vegetation cover 表示有改善

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument above?

 A) In the western United States, private land is typically more lush than public land, and cattle that graze on prive land can be fattened more quickly. ->IR

 B) Since the 1930's, recreational users of public land in the western United States have caused more environmental damage than have the cattle grazing there.

C) During the 1930's, an unusually destructive dtrought prevailed thoughout the region where most public lands in the western United States are located. .->IR

D) Ranchers who use public land in the western United States pay only a fraction of what is paid by those who lease comparable private land for grazing. .->IR

E) The amount of land purchased by the United States government since the 1930's is relatively insignificant.->IR

boston8899

ans?

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-1-15 6:37:33编辑过]

Lily0515

不好意思…仔细想了一下这道题应该是A因要WEAKEN the argument

就是要找确实Grazing livestock有造成改善才对..

至于B应该是SUPPORT the argument

请楼主提供ans??

我不确定我的分析对不?

 

请指教