| 我的写作心得:好处是:有了自己的整体框架思路;比较了不同写法对于我的适应性,选取了其中一些更合适我的;反复斟酌句子的写法,使得文章从刚一开始的罗罗嗦嗦不知所云的草稿,变成了现在言简意赅的半成品,自我感觉不错。缺点是太慢了,扣得实在太细了,在写作初期实在是没有必要。 这是我的第一篇作品(224第一篇),呵呵。 In this argument the author reaches the conclusion that with its long experience of 25 years in frozen foods area, the minimum costs and maximum profits of Olympic Foods can be expected. To support this prediction, the author claims a general principle that organizations will become more efficient as they learn how to do things better over time. The author also cites color film processing as an example in support of this conclusion. At first glance, the argument appears to be somehow plausible, but further reflection reveals that it suffers from at least 2 logic flaws. To begin with, the argument assums that the 25-year experience will automatically lead to the efficiency of Olympic Foods according to the general principle cited. However, this is not necessarily the case. It is possible that frozen foods industry is quite unique and therefore is an exception to the general principle. If so, the argument cannot justify its prediction that the long experience of Olympic Foods will result in its efficiency with minimum costs, at least not based on a mere general principle. In the second place, the author commits a fallacy of false analogy in assuming that frozen foods processing will achieve the same result as color-film processing does. The reasoning is questionable because similarities between the two industries are quite limited, while the differences are quite some. For example, the storage technology, the warehouse requirement, and the fresh status of products are all quite different. Therefore, the fact that the color-film processing succeeds in minimizing costs and maximizing profits does not support directly to the success of Olympic Foods. In sum, the argument is not well reasoned. To strengthen the conclusion, the author need to demonstrate that fozen foods processing is one of the normal industries to which the general principle applies. In addition, it would be better for the author to provide more concrete evidence to show that the example of color-film processing can lead to the expectation of the success of Olympic Foods, or maybe change to a new example which can function more directly.  
 [此贴子已经被作者于2007-10-28 1:00:54编辑过] |