黄皮11版OG, 53题，367页

kallyli

因为没有电子版的og这样写题目了, 请随时更正

The passage suggests wwhich of the following about the use of temporary employment by firms during the 1980's

A。It enabled firms to deal with fluctuating product demand far more efficiently than they did before the 1980's.

原文
Some observers have attributed the dramatic growth in temporary employment that occured in the US during the 1980's to increased participation in the workforce by certain groups.....

Instead,these analyses suggest that factors affecting employers account for the rise in temporary employment. One factor is product demand: templorary employment is favored by employers who are adapting to fluctuating demand for products while....

原文新老观点对比, 第二段的新观点说多雇佣临时工可使employers更适应fluctuating demand,第一段说1980临时工数量增长,所以1980前临时工不如1980后多,所以1980前雇主不能像1980后那样deal with fluctuating product demand efficiently.

我认为A是对的.

但是OG的解释说原文没说1980前的情况,我很奇怪,这明明说了啊.而且此题是推理题,怎么可能明确说出来?

请牛牛帮忙解答一下

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-7-13 17:43:26编辑过]

kallyli

真受挫,第一次在阅读区发贴就没有人理,什么原因啊?

顶一下,希望牛牛们来看看

sen4sun

呵呵. 没文章人懒都不想翻书. 这个问题其实很简单. 你这是逻辑比较对象的错误. 这个选项其实出的很好... 选项A 如果说和没有使用temporary worker 前比起来更能handle product demand.  那就是对的. 但是比较是和 1980 前比. 你怎么知道 1980 前没用temporary worker 来对付fluctuating product demand 呢

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-7-14 12:05:43编辑过]

kallyli

谢谢答题，呵呵：-）

“你怎么知道 1980 前没用temporary worker 来对付fluctuating product demand 呢”，原句是temporary employment is favored by emloyers who are adapting to fluctuating demand, 适应fluctuating demand是employer,  不是temporary worker啊。

不过我现在想A的错误原因应该是这句话是说employer 适应fluctuating demand,而不是由于rise in templorary employment更适应fluctuating demand,adpting to fluctuating demand只是修饰语而不是主句。所以不构成比较。

不知这样解释对否。