[讨论]885 -section 3- 19

goodmaneri

885-section 3 -19

This one has not been discussed..

19.India is country with at least fifty majoy regional languages, of whom fourteen have official recognition.

A) of whom fourteen have official recognition.

C)fourteen of which are official recognized

The right answer is C

Why A  is not correct ?

Because in OG 11- 89

89.Presenters at the seminar, one who is blind , will demonstrate adaptive equipment that allowss visually

 impaired people to use computers.

A) one who

B) one of them who

C)and one of them who

D) one of whom

E) one of which

The answer is D

The explanation in OG is that the correct pronoun is whom

 because an objective case pronoun must be used following the preposition of .

can some MM tell me why? thank you.....

 

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-6-21 3:18:30编辑过]

行缘

我的理解：

885-section 3 -19

A的错误:　1)用whom指代language 2) A of B的形式不对，of B是介词词组做定语，不是状语，所以不能用 of B A的结构，2) have official recognition,不简洁。

而且 which也可以有宾格形式啊，你为什么觉得矛盾呢？

goodmaneri

Thank you 行缘

  which也可以有宾格形式....

 I know where is my problem now!!

people - who, which

object - which

Therefore,

 of whom 宾格形式 for people

 of which  宾格形式 for thing...

Is my conclusion correct ?       

行缘

以下是引用goodmaneri在2006-6-20 12:00:00的发言：

Thank you 行缘

  which也可以有宾格形式....

 I know where is my problem now!!

people - who, which

object - which

Therefore,

 of whom 宾格形式 for people

 of which  宾格形式 for thing...

Is my conclusion correct ?       

我同意，除了红字标的people-which?

carolhide

恳请LZ在标题中标明题号，以便惠及后人，感谢配合。

goodmaneri

 

people - who, whom

sorry, I forget to proofread what i type.

You are right.

Thank you!