GWD25-25-28 请大家帮忙看一下

mimixiaxia

要死了,受不了CD16,四篇阅读都做得郁闷的没话说,受打击

sssophie

如果是aaab的话，我四题全错。。。。

ops9900

对于这篇文章我简直无语了。。。

hf000

顶

riverquiet

    By early 1917 the Socialist

party had established itself as a

(20) major political presence in New

York City. New York Socialists,

whose customary spheres of

    struggle were electoral work and

    trade union organizing, seized the

(25) opportunity and quickly organized－－－－这里讲了SOCIALIST的企图

an extensive series of cost-of-

living protests designed to direct

the women’s movement toward

Socialist goals. Underneath the

(30) Socialists’ brief commitment to

cost-of-living organizing lay a

basic indifference to the issue

itself. While some Socialists did－－－－－－－而这里又讲该目标只是SOME SOCIALISTS的，大多数的S不是这么想的，

view price protests as a direct

(35) step toward socialism,
                most－－－－－－－－－大多数的想法

Socialists ultimately sought to

divert  the cost-of-living movement

into alternative channels of protest.

Union organizing, they argued,

(40) was the best method through which

to combat the high cost of living.

For others, cost-of-living or oganiz-

ing was valuable insofar as it led－－－－－－－这里的OTHERS是指的谁那？

women into the struggle for suf-

(45) frage, and similarly, the suffrage

struggle was valuable insofar as

it moved United States society

one step closer to socialism.

这里的OTHERS,指谁啊，是MOST SCOCIALIST么？这个段落结构很奇怪啊，看不懂啊，快考了，还有俩星期，NN帮忙啊

qianrene

以下是引用nickynicky在2007-8-10 16:38:00的发言：

我选ＤＡＡＢ

Q25

The author suggests which of the following about

the New York Socialists’ commitment to the cost-

of-living movement?

A.     It lasted for a relatively short period of time.

B.     It was stronger than their commitment to the

Suffrage struggle.

C.  It predated the cost-of-living protests that

Erupted in 1917.

D.  It coincided with their attempts to bring more

Women into union organizing.

E.  It explained the popularity of the Socialist

party in New York City.

社会党的commitment和他们bring more women into union organizing

的企图确实是同时发生的，文中没有提到社会党的这个commitment

持续了多长时间，只是说他们commit的其实并不是他们的ultimate

goalA应该是不对的。

Q26

It can be inferred from the passage that the goal

of the boycotting women was the

A.     achievement of an immediate economic

outcome

B.     development of a more socialistic society

C.     concentration of widespread consumer

protests on the more narrow issue of

food prices

D.  development of one among a number of

different approaches that the women

wished to employ in combating the high

cost of living.

E.  attraction of more public interest to issues

that the women and the New York Socialists

considered important.

 这个可以在原稳定位，第63行，they saw cheaper

 这个可以在原稳定位，第63行，they saw cheaper

 这个可以在原稳定位，第63行，they saw cheaper

 这个可以在原稳定位，第63行，they saw cheaper

food as a valuable end in itself. 这个valuable end就是

food as a valuable end in itself. 这个valuable end就是

food as a valuable end in itself. 这个valuable end就是

food as a valuable end in itself. 这个valuable end就是

她们

她们

她们

她们

的最终目的，她们要的一个结果。

C在原文找不到支持，文章从头到尾都在说消费者的

protest against high food prices，没有提到其

他类型的consumer protest.所以C答案说她们的目的

是“为了把广泛的消费者抗议活动集中到食品价格这个

更窄的范围内“是没有道理的。

---------------------------------------

Q27

Which of the following best states the function of the

passage as a whole?

A. To contrast the views held by the Socialist party

   and by the boycotting women of New York City

   on the cost-of-living issue

B. To analyze the assumptions underlying oppos-

   ing viewpoints within the New York Socialist

   party of 1917

C. To provide a historical perspective on different

   approaches to the resolution of the cost-of-

   living issue.

D.     To chronicle the sequence of events that led

to the New York Socialist party’s emergence

   as a political power

E. To analyze the motivations behind the Socialist

   party’s involvement in the women’s suffrage

   movement.

这个C答案的意思是，从历史的角度看当时

针对生活成本提高这个问题所提出的不同的

解决方案。原文没有提到人和resolution to

the cost of living，讨论的是社会党和妇女

对于这个抗议活动的不同看法。选A。

希望有人能继续讨论这篇文章。

我也选DAAB

26题绝对选A（虽然我开始也选成C了）定位在这里,urgent=immediate：妇女关注的立马见效的价格下降，而对应的社会学家则不是（同时也对应了25题的答案不该是A）

Although New Yorker's Social-

(50) ists saw the cost-of-living issue

as, at best ,secondary or tertiary

to the real task at hand, the boy-

cotters, by sharp contrast, joined

the price protest movement out of[DS1] 

(55) an urgent and deeply felt commit-

ment to the cost-of-living issue.

---

 [DS1]出于

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-10-13 14:29:28编辑过]

raikey

第25题,支持D,因为文中的brief不是"短暂的"意思,而是"简单的,仅仅"意思,表示程度而不是时间.

第26题,支持C.政客们利用妇女运动的过程是: 妇女抵制食品涨价→带领妇女抵制生活成本上涨(cost-of-living)→Union organizing→Socialism. 文章最后一段虽然有the boycotters, by sharp contrast, joined the price protest movement out of (55) an urgent and deeply felt commitment to the cost-of-living issue.,但是此时的boycotters已经被政客们所利用,他们对cost-of-living的理解与政客们对cost-of-living的理解不同,文章仅接着上面那句作了解释,"declining living standards caused by rising food prices drove these (60) women to protest."指出,boycotters抗争的原因就是食物涨价,这暗示boycotters认为"food prices = cost-of-living". 所以说boycotters的目的就是抵制食物涨价,她们并不关心其他东西的涨价.

第27题,支持A,因为C中的historical perspective有问题, 我认为historical perspective是指后人对前人的看法,而不是历史事件当事人的看法.

第28题,肯定选B,expedient权宜之计.

selinahsiao

以下是引用blsunday在2006-8-9 10:20:00的发言：

25我选的 E
27我选E
和大家的都不一样，难道我太弱？

 

痾…我27也选E…但最后认为25-28 DAAE

可能因为我的确RC很弱吧

但我认为B错因为文中并没提出assumption

C和D我也忍为是错误的

因为C有historical 这字解释为有时间上的详述

文中并没有提到时间的重要性也没提出resolution

D选项chronicle 详述事件的结果这应该也不是讨论的中心

我个人浅见在AE之间徘徊
  

E 则是因为文中强调社会党的动机

虽然有些社会党人确实把价格抗议作为通向社会主义的直接手段

但是大多数人却只把抗议当作一种管道
  真正最好的方法是组织工会来对抗昂贵生活

其它人则认为抗议或是工会组织只有引导妇女为选举权斗争时才有意义存在

而选举斗争的目的是在于推动美国走向社会主义

社会党把生活成本抗议放在次要

抗争者才是真正为了生活成本而抗议着

但是
  后来想了一下

A比E好是因为强调了妇女和社会党彼此的动机做比较
  

E只有强调社会党动机既然是main idea 题型

整篇架构还是A好一些

26题

我原本也选A 因为总认为杯葛的妇女目的是为了获得立即的经济结果

(使大众重视物价高涨希望物价下跌)
 所以才选择抗议

A的定位在文章後面line 55

the boy-

cotters, by sharp contrast, joined

the price protest movement out of

(55) an urgent and deeply felt commit-

ment to the cost-of-living issue.

 但是后来看了C选项困惑了
 因為文中line 9后段开始到line17

The boycott shut.

(10) down much of the City’s foodstuffs

    marketing for two weeks, riveting

    public attention on the issue of

    food prices, which had increased

    partly as a result of increased

(15) exports of food to Europe that had

    been occurring since the outbreak

of the First World War.    

强调了杯葛的妇女不买菜这行动让公众注意食品价格问题
  (一次世界大战爆发造成出口食物增加)

而C是说 把广泛消费者的抗议活动(针对不同方面的高价格议题cost-of-living)集中到时品价格这狭隘的议题上吸引大众注意
  

PLZ! discuss! >"<

25 support D

因为社会党只是把选举和组织工会作为手段
却不是他们真正的目的

(他们真正目的是让美国走向社会主义)

但是却"巧合"促使妇女组织工会来对抗昂贵物价

28 Support E

答案B 错

因为 only用字不准确
文中没有武断字眼出现

而且也不该用goals ? 复数用法

不论some socialists 或most socialists应该只有一个目标

就是将美国迈向社会主义

Union organizing, they argued,

(40) was the best method through which

to combat the high cost of living.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-11-15 20:35:54编辑过]

confidence08

oh,my god! what is the right answer?

hollygrail

A A A B