[求助]做PREP时碰到的逻辑题

adele07smile

[attachimg]46411[/attachimg]

点击看大图

我觉得D不错啊

是典型的not+weaken结构啊

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-4-24 15:43:23编辑过]

入画

A是对的。 如果以前很多人有收音机，但没有发射站，听不了节目。现在发射站建多了，尽管收音机数量没变，听众也增加了。

D 取非之后好象活见鬼啊，没有收音机都能收到节目,哇哇。

adele07smile

D 取非之后是，没有配备RDS的收音机都能收到节目

我觉得是这个意思

司香尉

谁能把A这个句子的语法结构帮忙分析一下？我都看晕了

Few if any of the RDS radio stations that began broadcasting in Verdland after 1994(修饰radio stations) broadcast to people with RDS-equipped radios living in areas not previously reached by RDS stations(修饰前面的areas).

那么难道FEW是主句，从句是后面这一大串？

司香尉

LZ的取非好像不对啊。D的主语是people，没有收音机所以不能听到节目正常，但是取非后，人没有收音机能听到节目，是挺怪的。

我查了字典，Few if any of 就是few of 的意思。这下明白句子意思了。

tinaliu1985

D取非以后是说没有收音机的人也可以听到,那么虽然收音机数量没变,但人数增加了.很明显的削弱啊

wycg

以下是引用司香尉在2006-4-24 16:50:00的发言：

谁能把A这个句子的语法结构帮忙分析一下？我都看晕了

Few if any of the RDS radio stations that began broadcasting in Verdland after 1994(修饰radio stations) broadcast to people with RDS-equipped radios living in areas not previously reached by RDS stations(修饰前面的areas).

那么难道FEW是主句，从句是后面这一大串？

Few (主语)if any of the RDS radio stations that began broadcasting in Verdland after 1994 broadcast to
  (谓语)people(宾语) with RDS-equipped radios living in areas not previously reached by RDS stations.

A是对的.A大概是在说"现在那些新加上的发射站并没有用来服务那些有能力接收信息但是原来并没有被服务的设备".   也就是说并没有这种情况发生:  以前有很多设备由于缺乏发射站而没有被使用.

TO: 6楼的mm,

D"没有设备的人不能接收information"是个无关选项.

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-5-23 17:19:28编辑过]

zimerman

顶一个！

shinycrystal

如果A是对的。那么听众也增加了，岂不是与原题最后一句矛盾？

tylergu2

agree to wycg

A:

in the past, same radio can not receive program because lack of station

now, station ++, station serves those (who previously could not received program) nearly no increase...

therefore, if radio no increase, then receiving program no increase

D:

no radio, no program <-> have program, have radio , has nothing to do with radio station and people reciviing program