西班牙的ie好还是esade好啊

leosway

financial times 上面ie排名比较高，但wsj上面esade却领先很多。

有传闻说ie玩的说数字游戏，在西班牙人眼里esade和iese才是顶尖的商学院。

有没有达人了解真实情况的啊？

giraffe

你这个问题不好回答，比如英国人眼里顶尖的商学院，法国人眼里顶尖的商学院，其实大家都知道答案。但有很多时候，其实这个答案对个人选择并没有参考价值。本人知道有限，不过IESE给我印象不错，接触到的学生谈吐很好，不过这也只是个案，没有统计上的意义。至于IE和ESADE，有几个家伙排球打得不错，篮球好像弱点。

淡蓝色的回忆

right! iese > esade > ie

zjna

The ranking is only a rough reference.

No ideas what the Spanish comment on these three schools.

My personal experience about IE:

Strong points: 1. relatively short period, saving time and money

               2.  scholarship for Chinese

               3. a fully internationalized student body, this year students from 50 countries.

               4. Madrid is a nice city

               5. strong infulences in South America.

Weak points: 1. It is a private school, not eligible public funding.

             2. unsufficient career supports

             3. low reputation in China

             4. the life is tough, because of high competition and short period.

The other two schools are based in Barcelno,which has beutiful beach and stronger industries.

dannywhw

  2. unsufficient career supports

  3. low reputation in China

肺腑之言，但是ALSA奖学金能去掉一半的学费，20KEUR呢!

Gracias

你们别难为Zjna了。

单独比较排名没有任何意义。Dirk说了选择MBA像是在品红酒。

不能光看学校。如果学校工作机会不好的话，免100%学费也不会有人去的。

每个人的时间都是有价值的，你花的时间成本也要考虑的。

整体而言,IE, IESE, ESADE都是欧洲著名商学院，都不错。

我行我歌

As far as I know from the alumni of ESADE, It is really good, as competitive as IESE, the Spanish do think that IE is not so good;Esade especially have a good reputation in EU; You are right that ESADE have a good reputation in USA too, ranked 4th outside USA in the Businesss week.

the alumni of ESADE 2005 from Asia all go to work in wonderful companies, one Chinese boy goes to work in GE Guangzhou, one Janpanese works in the Famous football CLUB  Bararolla FC, another Janpanese works in the biggest Tele company in Janpan.

In fact, I got the offer from ESADE too. To me, the tution fee seems expensive, so i am hesitate.

Anyway,good luck to you!

zjna

Last month, there was a MBA tournament in Barcelona. Participants from IE, IESE and ESADE hold a warm-up for the coming European MBA tournament chaired by HEC. What I heard from my classmates is some of the students from ESADE are a bit arrogant and bellicose.

As for ranking, there are tons of arguments. It seems that for European schools the ranking from FT is much more treasured. The BW highly concentrates on US. My personal view: US top 10 and European Top 3 really make different.

Kindly inform me who is the Spanish you mention in “Spanish do think that IE is not so good”.

Have you ever talked to any Spanish? If so, what kind of people? The administration of ESAD?

Hope you have a wonderful MBA!

leosway

以下是引用giraffe在2006-4-4 21:13:00的发言：

你这个问题不好回答，比如英国人眼里顶尖的商学院，法国人眼里顶尖的商学院，其实大家都知道答案。但有很多时候，其实这个答案对个人选择并没有参考价值。本人知道有限，不过IESE给我印象不错，接触到的学生谈吐很好，不过这也只是个案，没有统计上的意义。至于IE和ESADE，有几个家伙排球打得不错，篮球好像弱点。

^_^，你太高校了，呵呵

leslieshih

IESE enjoys a better international reputation than other Spanish B-Schools... it also has larger elite alumni pool