CD历史遗留问题，逻辑大虾请进 (之一)

oldreaper

以下是引用freegirl在2003-9-7 10:15:00的发言：
  -------------------------3---------------------------------------------------
10. Almost all of the books published in the past 150 years were printed on acidic paper. Unfortunately, every kind of acidic paper gradually destroys itself due to its very acidity. This process of deterioration can be slowed if the books are stored in a cool, dry environment. Techniques, which are now being developed, to deacidify
books will probably be applied only to books with historical significance.

If all of the statements in the passage above are true, which one of the following must also be true!
(A) If a book was published in the past 50 years and is historically insignificant, it will probably deteriorate completely.
(B) Almost all of the books published in the past 150 years will gradually destroy themselves.
(C) Almost all of the books that gradually deteriorate are made of acidic paper.
(D) If a book is of historical significance and was printed before 150 years ago, it will be deacidified.
(E) Books published on acidic paper in 1900 should now all be at about the same state of deterioration.

我的问题是:　A不是犯了绝对化的错误吗？completely? 而且如果把不重要的书存放在干爽的地方，也还是可以减慢酸化的嘛。 原文在这里不就是一个让步吗？所以我第一个就排除了A.

A没有犯了绝对化的错误， (A) If a book was published in the past 50 years and is historically insignificant, it will probably deteriorate completely.

这里的50year 应该是 150year. 可能是抄错了

freegirl

oh, 明白了！明白了！谢谢！谢谢！

jq_jou

1. 所以A正好建立一个这种情况：医生在病人来之前必须准备好病例，不管病人是否要求看病例。
质疑: be ready to =be prepared to 表示准备发生, 还没有发生

2.D) Each child was able to identify correctly only the utensils that he had used. 这个最简单，如果child不能识别别人的，他就不会在别人的rolling bin中选出自己的
质疑: 我选了D), 不理解为什么错. 不认识别人的不代表不能选出自己的. 我觉得可能是UTENSIL> ROLLING STONE, 原文换成ROLLING STONE, 就是RIGHT CHOICE, 你觉得呢?

oldreaper

D) Each child was able to identify correctly only the utensils that he had used. 这个最简单，如果child不能识别别人的，他就不会在别人的rolling bin中选出自己的
质疑: 我选了D), 不理解为什么错. 不认识别人的不代表不能选出自己的. 我觉得可能是UTENSIL> ROLLING STONE, 原文换成ROLLING STONE, 就是RIGHT CHOICE, 你觉得呢?

D) Each child was able to identify correctly only the utensils that he had used.

这里的only, 通过题你推不出来。 我的回答中包括了child能识别别人的rolling pin的可能性， 所以only在这里不成立