- UID
- 1527603
- 在线时间
- 小时
- 注册时间
- 2022-9-16
- 最后登录
- 1970-1-1
- 主题
- 帖子
- 性别
- 保密
|
发表于 2022-12-3 17:00:52
|
显示全部楼层
Day 71
1. 不招待见的风力发电
Scientist: wind turbine affect wind pattern and change the climate condition. The real solution is to minimize our energy consumption or else all energy alternatives will damage the environment like fossil-fuel.
Q: Support
P: wind turbine affect environment
C: the real solution will damage the environment
Gap: wind turbine ——the real solution——damage the environment
支持的方向:能量守恒定律,所有的能量alternatives都需要牺牲自然资源
转换energy需要大量耗电
2. 工厂与员工生病
A factory uses some kind of spray to dye something. In high concentration (of the spray) factory, 70% worker developed some kind of disease. In lower concentration factory, 30% workers got the same disease. Therefore, if a factory reduces the usage of spray, workers will not develop the disease.
Q: What weaken the argument?
P:high concentration factory 70% worker developed disease; In lower concentration factory, 30% workers got the disease.
C:reduce the usage of spray——will not develop the disease
Gap:spray——disease
削弱的方向:找他因
- High concentration factory is always located in developing country or rural area, where the sanitary condition is incredibly poor.
- High concentration factory requires a lot of employees working at the same time in a small plant, where is lack of the ventilation.
3. 电影片头的广告
说广告原本一直插播在TV里,然后大家总是不看,然后公司决定把它插播到电影开头,是削弱题
P: 插播在TC——总是不看
C:插播在电影开头
Gap:插播在电影开头——有人看?
削弱题:多数人是在电影开通以后才到达电影院的。
观众往往会跳过电影开头。
|
|