请问长江：香港科大要合并长江，是真的吗？

sky_river

每个M&A都必须在PMI阶段面对一些挑战，不能说PMI会遇到问题就否定整个case，如果按照victorcorleone逻辑的话，世界上的任何一个M&A都不要进行了。

victorcorleone你提的问题只是长江和科大PMI中一小部分问题，你能想到的问题，长江和科大的executive们都会想到的。发现问题谁都会，关键是能否有能力提出解决的方法。也许这就是我们所要提高的地方。我代表长江新一届的同学多谢你的关注，同时也请你多注意自己的身体。我想长江和科大M&A会成为下一届的教学案例，到时如果你想知道这些问题的解决方法，随时欢迎您来和我们沟通。 msn: river_ck(A) hotmail.com

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-8-30 21:24:53编辑过]

amarkiu

Don't know whether Sinoyuan is on his international trip to HK and Singapore. If so,victorcorleone need wait patiently for his coming back. For me, I really keen to know who is Sinoyuan and eager to make friend with him.

The reason why I want to join CK is because it has big dream. Even it can not reach the target, it will not far away from it. 10 years is enough for CK to prove itself whether it can reach the goal.I want to work hard and share the big dream with CK.I heard the goal of ShangHai is oriental Paris, while the goal of ShenYang is Northern ShenZhen. You can feel the differences between the two cities. For the MBA programs, we also can find such differences.

A coming CK guy.

victorcorleone

以下是引用sky_river在2005-8-30 21:16:00的发言：

每个M&A都必须在PMI阶段面对一些挑战，不能说PMI会遇到问题就否定整个case，如果按照victorcorleone逻辑的话，世界上的任何一个M&A都不要进行了。

victorcorleone你提的问题只是长江和科大PMI中一小部分问题，你能想到的问题，长江和科大的executive们都会想到的。发现问题谁都会，关键是能否有能力提出解决的方法。也许这就是我们所要提高的地方。我代表长江新一届的同学多谢你的关注，同时也请你多注意自己的身体。我想长江和科大M&A会成为下一届的教学案例，到时如果你想知道这些问题的解决方法，随时欢迎您来和我们沟通。 msn: river_ck(A) hotmail.com

我觉得我提的问题可能是一小部分问题，但也是关键问题。关键问题不解决，显然合并是不会成功的。然而，因为各有各的利益，完美的解决方案显然不会有。任何一个M&A都是各利益相关方谈判和妥协的过程。

我提出这些问题，只是建议CK的同学们能从自己的利益出发，参与到整个合并过程中去，争取自己的利益。而不是以这种事不关己的态度来对待。

当然，你觉得我是多管闲事，居心叵测，那是你的想法，我也不会怪你。只是希望你和你的同学们好好考虑我的建议。

purplekitty

First of all, I should say thank you to victorcorleone for your always concern shown to CKGSB. It also enlightens me to further examine CKGSB.

I always think that for anybody, to give up job and to choose any full-time MBA program should be a risk-taking decision, either in temporary financial situation, or in future career development, or in family consideration, or in something else. Especially for those people who have chosen CKGSB, it also means that they have chosen to take more risk to grow up together with a young business school. Till now, people can see CKGSB’s constant efforts to approach a world-class business school. In my view, CKGSB’s management know their responsibilities quite well and they have determination and capability to make things go towards the school’s goal.

BTW, thanks to modern science and technology development, now we have many sources to get kinds of information. It is good to share information and ideas with others, but it is not so good to try to use personal ideas to impact others. Adequate respect to different thoughts should be an essential requirement to a successful man or woman.

freeagle

别的人我不知道，基本上郎咸平是要回到CUHK去了。

长江其实不用这么敏感，被科大合并不是什么丢人的事，只是可能对某些人有点损失。

klipper

It's very interesting discussion for me because obviously people here have a lot of inside information.



Victorcorleone is not positive about the M&A. She seems to have
very good reasons though she did not metioned here all. Amarkiu holds
very strong position too. He even said it's CKGSB  buy over
HKUST  rather than a M&A. Let us just wait and see more
details coming out.



It's also very interesting to me that people here are really care about
the whole management education but not some specific school. It's not
very common for a harvard student to say something about yale or vice
versa. victorcorleone,
you are great. A harvard student would be happy to see if yale doomed
but you really cares about those who had a different choice.

foever

长江很新，需要一段时间，三五年内猜测、误解和非议是情理之中的,变数很多。同时长江如果很烂，连与科大谈合作的机会都不会有，更别说非常密切的合作。前一段时间遇到一个比较内部的人说，科大师资的平均水平不如长江,当然长江教授很少,容易做到少而精。这个说法有其道理，长ersonName w:st="on" ProductID="江的">江的ersonName>教授基本上都是顶尖商学院很厉害的老师，尤其是课程改革后。说到教授要看整体水平而不是看某一两个人。

waterg

前两天东京的World MBA Tour上，很失望没有看到长江的身影。不论这件事是真是假，希望中国本土（包括香港）在不久的将来造就出世界顶尖bschool。

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-11-7 16:57:28编辑过]

tigerspeed

长江商学院，成长中，前景可期。

2005届学生就业前景不错，分布均匀，大部分学生成功实现转换行业或功能的理想。

供参考。

祝所有报考长江的学生好运。