OG-179

统一绿茶

请教OG-179
A museum has been offered an undocumented statue, supposedly Greek and from the sixth century BC. Possibly the statue is grenuine but undocumented because it was recently unearthed or because it has been privately owned.However, an ancient surface usually has uneven weathering , whereas the surface of this statue has the uniform quliaty characteristically produced by a chemical bath used by forgers to imitate a weathered surface. Therefore,the statue is pribably a fogery

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

(A) Museums can accept a recently unearthed statue only with valid export documentation from its country of origin.

(B) The subject’s pose and other aspects of the subject’s treatment exhibit all the most common features of Greek statues of the sixth century B.C.

(C) The chemical bath that forgers use was at one time used by dealers and collectors to remove the splotchy surface appearance of genuinely ancient sculptures.

(D) Museum offcials believe that forgers have no technique that can convincingly simulate the patchy weathering characteristic of the surfaces of ancient sculptures.

(E) An allegedly Roman sculpture with a uniform surface similar to that of the stature being offered to the museum was recently shown to be a forgery.

D为何不对呢,我看了相关连接,好象说的不太清楚

livary

D： forgers have no technique that can convincingly simulate the patchy weathering characteristic of the surfaces of ancient sculptures.而题目中说到the surface of this statue has the uniform quliaty characteristically produced by a chemical bath used，也就是说this statue并没有the patchy weathering characteristic of the surfaces，这样D也就不构成削弱了，我认为是无关选项。

其实我也是今天做到这题没有做对，但是我想如果好好看看OG的解释应该是很有帮助的。

[此贴子已经被作者于2005-9-8 22:13:07编辑过]

yangxiaogang

还是不明白为何选B,请高人指点，多谢

yangxiaogang

怎么没有人回答？谢谢

yangxiaogang

ding

littledou

结论是这个物品可能是假的。B选项说这个物品有6世纪希腊东西的特征，但真货和假货都可能有这些共同的特征，B起不到削弱的作用。

coolhany

D.因为原文中的whereas说明statue不是Uneven的!

那么D中说的patchy weathering characteristic就和它无关了。

amber0919

amber0919

不明白

bananayang

7楼说的很明确，题干中说this statue has the uniform quliaty ，所以D选项中说造假者没有能力造成patchy weathering characteristic ，与该statue的uniform quliaty 没有关系。