快考了，还有GWD的不会，求助~！GWD-13-Q15

jyw0411lsq

求助Q31: FF-19
Q31: FF-19.

Jane: Televisionprograms and movies that depict violence among teenagers are extremely popular. Given how influential these media are, we have good reason to believe that these depictions cause young people to engage in violent behavior. Hence, depictions of violence among teenagers should be prohibited from movies and televisionprograms, if only in those programs and movies promoted to young audiences.

Maurice: But you are recommending nothing short of censorship! Besides which, your claim that television and movie depictions of violence cause violence is mistaken: violence among young people predates movies and television by centuries.

Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens Jane’s argument?



A.The most violent characters depicted in movies and on televisionprograms are adult characters which are portrayed by adult actors.

B.The movies that have been shown to have the most influence on young people’s behavior are those that are promoted to young audiences.

C.The people who make the most profits in the movie and television industry are those who can successfully promote their work to both young and old audiences.

D.Many adolescents who engage in violent behavior had already displayed such behavior before they were exposed violence in movies.

E.Among the producers who make both movies and televisionprograms, many voluntarily restrict the subject matter of films directed toward young audiences


答案B,   可是我就是纠结BE的答案，E为什么不对？谢谢；！

cycyang

似乎明白了

“Hence, depictions of violence among teenagers should be prohibited from movies and televisionprograms, if only in those programs and movies promoted to young audiences.”  结论是应该禁止面向年轻观众的电影中的暴力镜头。

反驳：你推荐的办法无异于审核制度，没有新意。同时，你的因果关系不清，暴力的存在是人的本性而不是电影镜头推动的。


B.The movies that have been shown to have the most influence on young people’s behavior are those that are promoted to young audiences.
实践证明最能影响年轻人行为的电影是面向年轻观众的电影。（若此为真，说明如果面向年轻观众的电影中有很多暴力镜头，很有可能鼓动年轻人的暴力行为。因而，禁止这种镜头显然对于制止年轻人的暴力倾向有帮助。）

cycyang

不甚明白，所以搜索了一下，http://forum.chasedream.com/GMAT_CR/thread-376172-1-7.html

cycyang

E.Among the producers who make both movies and televisionprograms, many voluntarily restrict the subject matter of films directed toward young audiences

同时制作电影和电视节目的制作人中，很多都是主动限制面向年轻观众的电影主题。（我想问题是：所谓的标准是倾向于有暴力镜头还是没有暴力镜头，答案无从而知）