揽瓜阁做题小分队 第27天 智力模型：单一与多元

小白斩鸡

请大家在本帖回复：

1. 文章大概结构

2. 自己写的答案

解析+文章翻译明晚微信群里公布

Until recently, nearly everyone thought of intelligence as a single entity that could be measured by a simple IQ test. In 1983, however, Dr. Howard Gardner, a professor of education at Harvard University, introduced his theory of multiple intelligences. Today, there are two major schools of thought on intelligence. Despite extensive and ongoing research, scientists have been unable to prove definitively one theory over the other.

The single intelligence model is based on the idea of one general intelligence, known as positive manifold or simply g. Perhaps the most convincing evidence in support of this theory is the fact that individuals who perform well on tests of one cognitive ability also perform well on tests of a second cognitive ability. For example, those who do well on verbal tests also do well on mathematics tests, and vice versa. Another argument in support of the general intelligence theory is the strong positive correlation between intelligent quotient, or IQ, as measured by psychometric tests, and reaction time. Individuals with faster reaction times or neural processing speeds have higher IQs, suggesting that neural processing speed is equivalent to the one general intelligence.

The theory of multiple intelligences asserts that there is more than one type of intelligence. Proponents of this model differ on the number of intelligences. Gardner, for example, originally proposed seven, but has since added an eighth. His categories are linguistic, logical-mathematical, musical, spatial, bodily kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalist. Dr. Robert Sternberg, a professor of psychology and education at Yale University, proposes a triarchic theory of intelligence, which divides intelligence into three categories: analytical, creative, and practical. Gardner’s theory is supported primarily by biological evidence. By studying individuals with paralysis, speech impairment, or other disabilities, Gardner has been able to identify specific parts of the brain associated with different physical and cognitive skills. Sternberg’s model relies on observations of real-life situations. He notes that in Brazil, for example, street children can do the math they need to know to survive, thereby demonstrating practical intelligence, but cannot pass a school math class, which requires analytical intelligence.

1. The author mentions the correlation between IQ and reaction time in order to
(A) provide justification for Howard Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences
(B) explain the triarchic model of intelligence proposed by Robert Sternberg
(C) introduce the idea of positive manifold
(D) point out one argument in support of general intelligence
(E) prove that the single intelligence model is superior to the theory of multiple intelligences

2. It can be inferred from the passage that
(A) the theory of multiple intelligences is more prominent than the single intelligence model
(B) the traditional view of intelligence has been challenged in recent years
(C) there is no biological evidence for Sternberg’s model
(D) street children in Brazil would not do well on standard IQ tests
(E) the theory of multiple intelligences has been adopted by some schoolteachers

3. According to the passage, the term “positive manifold” can be most closely identified with which of the following?
(A) The correlation between IQ and reaction time
(B) The observation that individuals with speech impairment are able to demonstrate other forms of intelligence
(C) The relationship between IQ and performance on standardized tests
(D) The three intelligences proposed by Dr. Robert Sternberg
(E) Neural processing speed

4. The author of this passage would most likely agree with which of the following?
(A) The theory of multiple intelligences is relatively new and untested.
(B) Within the next decade, discoveries about the human brain will resolve the debate about intelligence.
(C) Dr. Sternberg’s theory would be strengthened by the discovery of biological evidence for his conclusions.
(D) The theory of multiple intelligences is undermined by disagreements among its proponents as to the number of intelligences.
(E) There is stronger biological evidence in favor of the single-intelligence model than of the theory of multiple intelligences.

参考答案：

DBEC

andyhhhh

DDEC

B及站士

0

B及站士

P1.
1. Two theory: “single intelligence” vs. “multiple intelligences”
2. Scientists: unable to prove one theory over the other

P2.
1. Theory(1): Single intelligence( one general intelligence) – “positive manifold”
2. Supporting idea(1): individuals who perform well on one test also do well on another
3. Supporting idea(2): IQ ∝ reaction time – neural processing speed = one general intelligence

P3.
1. Theory(2): multiple intelligences – more than one type of intelligence (differ on the number)
2. Example: Gardner(7 to 8), Robert Sternberg(ttriarchic thoery)
3. Supporting ideas: G – biological evidence ; S – observations of real-life situations

大月亮cyn

Day27 DBAC
3. E 第二段首尾两句联系，general intelligence known as = positive manifold， 最后一句 neural processing speed = general intelligence

崔大套

DCBA

huluzhu

DCAD

690387114

EBAA
DBEC
题3 定位句suggesting that neural processing speed is equivalent to the one general intelligence.is based on the idea of one general intelligence, known as positive manifold or simply g
所以one general intelligence= positive manifold=IQ=Neural processing speed
A选项是支撑的论据，identify with“等于”
题4 两个theory都没有test过,都只是提出theory+支撑论据，所以说multiple theory相对one  general theory来，relatively untested就错了。
Sternberg’s model relies on observations,所有有些别的支撑会更有说服力些

SchodingerCat

DBEC

ccccherry

DCAA