1227 裸机JJ 23 人生规划

VincentShu · 发表于 2012-1-18 13:52:34

23、【人生规划】求GWD考古
两组不同的人，都遭受过失败，一组是有人生规划的，一组是没有人生规划的，有人生规划的那组比没有人生规划那组后来更成功。所以要有人生规划才能走出挫折。问作者错在啥地方？
答案有：A，作者忽略了没有受过挫折的人也会有人生规划
B，作者忽略了有人生规划的人也有失败的。
C，作者认为有人生规划的人反倒可能造成失败。By hechaoo

大家看看这题选什么啊？

pollotosin · 发表于 2012-1-18 13:57:41

好像都不是

VincentShu · 发表于 2012-1-18 14:01:15

我觉得能推出：在受过挫折的人里面，有人生规划的更能走出挫折（B集合）。原文结论：有人生规划的更能走出挫折（A集合）A包含了B所以忽略了那些，没有受过挫折的，有人生规划的。

pollotosin · 发表于 2012-1-18 14:13:07

那得看选项里有没有你这个结论才行

VincentShu · 发表于 2012-1-18 14:14:01

照这么看，答案就是A哦～只是不知道思路对不对

千与千寻117 · 发表于 2012-1-18 17:52:45

不知道这么想对不对 LS说集合提醒了我假如这个大集合分为四种
挫折+有人生规划 A 没挫折+有人生规划 B
挫折+没人生规划 C 没挫折+没人生规划 D
如果把成功理解为比较大小要像强调人生规划的正面效应A+B>C+D
题目说A>C
要像强调人生规划的正面效应就应该让D小，即假如没挫折+没人生规划人成功的太多，也说明不了人生规划的正面效应，所以应该让没挫折+有人生规划后来成功的多一些
这个是有可能作者忽略的

VincentShu · 发表于 2012-1-18 19:48:42

那LS觉得应该选什么样的选项？

dajdaj · 发表于 2012-1-18 22:29:27

求答案@@顶

sdcar2010 · 发表于 2012-1-20 22:19:47

The answer is none of the above. I hate Chinese version of GMAT or LSAT questions, because sometime the translation gets into the way.

The key is to look at the conclusion: 要有人生规划才能走出挫折。This conclusion says that having a career plan is NECESSARY for overcoming setbacks.

A flaw would be: The author assumes that for those who had no career plan, NONE of them overcame their setbacks.

A weakener would be: Someone who overcame setbacks did not have a career plan.

Again, the above analysis is based on the assumption that the Chinese translation is correct.

qiuhua01234567 · 发表于 2012-1-20 22:55:38

The answer is none of the above. I hate Chinese version of GMAT or LSAT questions, because sometime the translation gets into the way.

The key is to look at the conclusion: 要有人生规划才能走出挫折。This conclusion says that having a career plan is NECESSARY for overcoming setbacks.

A weakener would be: Someone who overcame setbacks did not have a career plan.

Again, the above analysis is based on the assumption that the Chinese translation is correct.

-- by 会员 sdcar2010 (2012/1/20 22:19:47)

大神出现总能圆满解决问题。。DDDD

1227 裸机JJ 23 人生规划

所属分类: GMAT考试

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

浏览过的版块