[求助]GWD-3-Q5,GWD-3-35

為什麼答案是b而不是c呢

文章中不是有提到很多質疑的觀點嗎~

為什麼不可以選c~~

謝謝指教~*^^*

=========

請問GWD-3-35的b錯在哪裡呢~

謝謝解答~

Q5:      

The passage asserts which of the following about the claim that ALH84001 originated on Mars?

1. It was initially proposed by the McKay team of scientists.
2. It is not a matter of widespread scientific dispute.
3. It has been questioned by some skeptics of the McKay team’s work.
4. It has been undermined by recent work on PAH’s.
5. It is incompatible with the face that ALH84001 has been on Earth for 13,000 years.

I am afraid that C means those skeptics are from MK's work.

Q35:

The passage suggests that the historian mentioned in the second paragraph (lines 19-42) would be most likely to agree with which of the following assertions regarding Alessandra Strozzi?

1. Alessandra was able to act more independently than most women of her time because she was a widow.
2. Alessandra was aware that her personal motivation was embedded in a social context.
3. Alessandra had goals and interests similar to those of many other widows in her society.
4. Alessandra is an example of a Renaissance woman who expressed her individuality through independent action.
5. Alessandra was exceptional because she was able to effect changes in the social constraints placed upon women in her society.

For B, we can not tell from the article whether Alessandra was aware or not.

可是D中的expressed her individuality through independent action.也不对吧，文章中不是说

yet much of the historian’s own

research reveals that Alessandra

acted primarily as a champion of her

(30)      sons’ interests, taking their goals as

her own.  Thus Alessandra conforms

more closely to the anthropologist’s

       notion that personal motivation is

embedded in a social context.

这样看来第二段应该是强调A的social relationships啊。而且从primarily as a champion of her sons’ interests应该可以看出 A aware her personal motivation。

请NN指点。

more closely to the anthropologist’s

       notion that personal motivation is

embedded in a social context.
是从研究人员的角度说的，是研究人员认为这个A的表现说明了个人动机是和社会结合的.但不能说A这个人已经站到这个高度,说我的动机就是和社会结合的.恐怕那时候根本没有这些概念呢，这些概念都是后来研究者在研究中提出的.

明白了，可是D中的through independent action.也找不到依据啊。

同意~~

我觉得更应该是C……麻烦大家讲讲

请读题干：...suggest that the historian mentioned...这里是个陷阱，问the historian的观点，她的观点和大多数历史学家的观念不同，即：This historian assumes that A had goals and interest different from those of her sons, YET much of ...她的观点是A不同，但是她的研究却揭示了A与其儿子之间的关联。因此the historian的观点是A是独立的，不同与她儿子们的。

re~~~~~