请教og 11 (综合)-48

some anthropologists study modern-day societies of foragers in an effort to learn about our ancient ancestors who were also foragers.A flaw in this strategy is that forager societies are extremely varied.Indeed, any forager society with which anthropologists are familiar with has had considerable contact with modern non-forager societies.

Which of the following, if true, would most weaken the criticism made above of the anthropolgists' strategy?

A) All forager societies throughout history have had a number of important features in common that are absent from other types of societies.

E) Even those modern-day forager societies that have not had significant contact with modern societies are importantly different from ancient forager societies.

答案是A，这个明白。但是我觉得E 也对啊。

E 的意思是说即使forager societies和现代社会没有联系也和古代的forager societies有很大不同。也就是说和现代社会的联系是无关紧要的。那不是就反驳第2种批评，“any forager society with which anthropologists are familiar with has had considerable contact with modern non-forager societies.” --forager society 和现代社会联系太多吗？

请教nn赐教。

要反驳的是“批评家认为用过去去了解现在不可行，因为变化太大”。

E的意思，恰好是说“变化太大”，这不是支持批评家么？

批评者批评的第一个原因是因为变化大。第二个原因我理解是因为forager society 和现代社会有联系，所以不行。不知道我对第二个原因的理解对不对？

继续请教。

恩，换成交流更好些，

批评者批评的第一个原因是因为变化大。第二个原因我理解是因为forager society 和现代社会有交流，所以不行。

E 的意思是说即使forager societies和现代社会没有交流也和古代的forager societies有很大不同。不就是说和现代社会的交流是无关紧要的，不会影响forager socities varied from 古代forager societies。那不是就反驳第2种批评吗？