天山3-4-5

seasnow

Q5:
According to the passage, which of the following is probably true of the storage spaces
mentioned in line 14?
A. They were used by the community elite for storage of their own food supplies.
B. They served a ceremonial as well as a practical function.
C. Their size is an indication of the wealth of the particular community to which they
belonged.
D. Their existence proves that the community to which they belonged imported large
amounts of food.
E. They belonged to and were used by the community as a whole.

B错再elite是下一段才提到的内容，而且说their own更加不对，their指的是elite。

D错在large amounts，文中说大部分还是自己生产的。

katie83

以下是引用云开在2005-11-9 8:06:00的发言：

支持4D, 5E

4D为他因削弱

5中L16的storage apace located around ....具有不确定性, 而L24 in such apparently communal space直接支持E

请指正

不同意第5题选E,原文没有明确的地方指出,也没有强调space为不同公社共有,communal space也不能说是几个公社共有的证据.

mba06

surely 4D 5E 6C

4. it gives another reason (religious) to explain why some burial site has mor stuff than others. It explains this uneven distribution is not caused by wealth.

5. definitely E. In US, community means group shared. Like community pool, it is used by  all families live in that community. communal is the same thing. Here is the explain in dictionary.com

communal

adj 1: for or by a group rather than individuals; "dipping each his bread into a communal dish of stew"- Paul Roche; "a communal settlement in which all earnings and food were shared"; "a group effort" 2: relating to a small administrative district or community; "communal elections in several European countries"

Of, belonging to, or shared by the people of a community; public.

tian shan answer sheet has too many errors than GWD answer. Not sure the one I have is the lastest.

mba06

 

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-6-14 15:19:09编辑过]

hawkinsxie

选了D,E,C

不过，中间那道争议太大！未有定论！

starskyly

投DEC一票啦

caterpillarcn

5E. 根本就不是ceremonial places嘛。这些东西只是围住ceremonial places而已。

beibeibear

第5题，支持b选项。 我觉得e错在“belong to" ,虽然原文中commual spaces 暗示了spaces 是公共使用的，但并不一定为公共所有。 此外，这虽然不是一个主题题，但我觉得可以结合文章主要内容考虑，本文主要在论证leadership elite 产生的必要性可能性，且说明了分工的出现，财富分配的不均衡等问题，所以侧重点应该在“分”而非“合”，用这种投机的方法也可选出答案b. 因为e显然与这个主题冲突了：）

wangrui523

自己选了E,可现在觉得E不对

因为即使说belonged to the community对,文中更没有提到were used by the community

晴天小狗

是不是可以这样看

问题是which of the following is probably true

而B说 served a ceremonial ，这一点是原文直接否定的：located around some communal Great Kivas

但是Ｅ选项还是有可能的　

还是Ｅ吧

但是Ｅ选项还是有可能的　

还是Ｅ吧