天山3-4-5

jennyb

支持E,

文中说the large size of storage spaces located around some communal Great Kivas (underground ceremonial chambers)， 后面的括号里是说Great Kivas是ceremonial chambers,不是说storage spaces, 所以b错

fatlara

同意楼上的

Jackie2005

Could someone post the question 6 and the answer?

Thanks a lot!!!

carcar

5支持E。用于储存只是推测。。。原文明确说，这是communal space

hannah1209

5 E

B 没有原文支持，Jennyb说的很清楚。

E belonged to and were used by the community as a whole对应原文中 apparently communal space

z520m

支持答案D,E,C,4应该是D,B是无关的，因为B说到了extensive,文章说的是intensive.5应该是E,虽然文章没有说be used as whole,可是如果是作为保存食物用

could have preserved

the necessary extra food, including

imported foodstuffs, in such appar-

ently communal spaces

那么应该是used as a whole,问的是probably阿！所以 used as a whole还是可能的！

而反观B,文章没有说such spaces用于ceremonial,只是around而已，没有probably,并且practice太宽泛了。如果敌人打过来时用于躲避，那么也是practice了??存食物算practice是我们自己假设的，可是为部落存食物确实used as a whole。

我给出了理由，希望各位指正，讨论出合适的答案。造福后人。

谢谢各位nn

yangxiaogang

我觉得应该是B,这里有一个概念的问题，处于公共区域的东西，不一定属于公共，而B选项则非常明确。在GMAT中，延伸一步很有可能就是谬误！

catq

B更直接，完全等同于L16 括号里的文字，(underground ceremonial chambers).。而such a communal place所属的那一句只是推测：Western Pueblo communities lacking sufficient arable land to support their populations could have preserved the necessary extra food, including imported foodstuffs, in such apparently communal spaces

云开

支持4D, 5E

4D为他因削弱

5中L16的storage apace located around ....具有不确定性, 而L24 in such apparently communal space直接支持E

请指正

ProteinMonica

第五题问的就是which of the following is probably true，所以E