ChaseDream
搜索
返回列表 发新帖
查看: 2050|回复: 6
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[求助]阅读大全 Passage 85 (22/22)

[复制链接]
楼主
发表于 2005-1-16 08:41:00 | 只看该作者

[求助]阅读大全 Passage 85 (22/22)

Passage 85 (22/22)


It is an unfortunate fact that most North Americans know little about American Indian culture and history. Scholars have studied such matters, but they have not succeeded in broadcasting their conclusions widely. Thus, it is still not widely known that American Indians have epics, that they performed plays long before Europeans arrived, and that they practiced politics and carried on trade.


One way to gain a fuller appreciation of this rich culture is to examine American Indian poetry, for poetry is in all cultures the most central and articulate of the arts. It is especially important that we study American Indian poetry as this poetry can create a context that gives cohesive expression to the crafts, the artifacts, and the isolated facts that many Americans have managed to notice willy-nilly . Even a survey of American Indian poetry reveals a range of poetic thought and technique that defies easy generalization. Jarold Ramsey hazards a summary, however, which serves at least to give the uninitiated reader some sense of what American Indian poetry is like. Overall, he writes, it represents “an oral, formulaic, traditional, and anonymous art form,” whose approach is to emphasize the “mythic and sacred” components of reality. It “flourished through public performances... by skilled recitalists whose audiences already knew the individual stories” and valued the performers for their “ability to exploit their material dramatically and to combine them [their stories] in longer cycles” rather than for their “plot invention.” Because this poetry belongs to highly ethnocentric tribal peoples, whose cultures “we still do not know much about,” it “is likely to seem all the more terse, even cryptic.”


American Indian poetry has another feature that Ramsey ignores: it is always functional. Whether sung, chanted, or recited; whether performed ceremonially, as entertainment, or as part of a task such as curing a patient or grinding corn; or whether recited individually or by a group, it is always fully woven into the fabric of ordinary life.


For complicated reasons, American Indian poetry has basically been ignored by non-Indian cultures. Kenneth Lincoln writes that failure to hear American Indian voices results “partly...from the tragedies of tribal dislocation, partly from mistranslation, partly from misconceptions about literature, partly from cultural indifference.” Brian Swann suggests an additional explanation: tribal poetry is oral, whereas Europeans arrived in the New World with a deeply ingrained belief in the primacy of the written word. As a result, European settles found it hard to imagine that poetry could exist without written texts and thus that the American Indians had achieved something parallel to what Europeans called literature long before Europeans arrived. As a consequence, Europeans did not fully respond to the rich vitality of American Indian poetry.


7.     Which of the following best describes the organization of the last paragraph of the passage?



(A) An observation is made and qualifications of it are provided.



(B) A phenomenon is noted and explanations for it are presented.



(C) A hypothesis is presented and arguments against it are cited.



(D) A prognosis is made and evidence supporting it is discussed


(E) A criticism is presented and information expanding it is provided.


第7题的答案说是 B. 可是我觉得E也有道理,为什么E不对呢?请大虾解惑,谢谢!


沙发
发表于 2005-1-17 12:39:00 | 只看该作者

For complicated reasons, American Indian poetry has basically been ignored by non-Indian cultures.
这更倾向于事实论述。

Kenneth Lincoln writes that failure to hear American Indian voices results “partly...from the tragedies of tribal dislocation, partly from mistranslation, partly from misconceptions about literature, partly from cultural indifference.”
引用KL的观点,无作者主观评价。

Brian Swann suggests an additional explanation: tribal poetry is oral, whereas Europeans arrived in the New World with a deeply ingrained belief in the primacy of the written word. As a result, European settles found it hard to imagine that poetry could exist without written texts and thus that the American Indians had achieved something parallel to what Europeans called literature long before Europeans arrived. As a consequence, Europeans did not fully respond to the rich vitality of American Indian poetry.
引用BS观点,无作者主观评价。

所以选B。

板凳
 楼主| 发表于 2005-1-19 12:30:00 | 只看该作者

(E) A criticism is presented and information expanding it is provided.

这里的information expanding it is provided.指的是: 提供了扩展这个评论的信息. 下面的内容确实不是作者的评价,但是也可以认为是--- 扩展了


For complicated reasons, American Indian poetry has basically been ignored by non-Indian cultures

这个评论的信息.

我说的是不是有道理?

地板
发表于 2005-1-23 11:37:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用egretxm在2005-1-19 12:30:00的发言:

(E) A criticism is presented and information expanding it is provided.


这里的information expanding it is provided.指的是: 提供了扩展这个评论的信息. 下面的内容确实不是作者的评价,但是也可以认为是--- 扩展了







For complicated reasons, American Indian poetry has basically been ignored by non-Indian cultures


这个评论的信息.


我说的是不是有道理?


你说的有点道理,但并不正确。ETS考察的就是一种准确的思维判断,"批评"和"评论"不同,"扩展评论"应当继续评论,而不是引用他人的观点。在这两方面都有点问题。这些思维是有差异的,或许细小。

一定要注意,这些往往就反映了ETS要考核的重点,必须必须认真对待

5#
 楼主| 发表于 2005-1-26 06:49:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用wangyu73cn在2005-1-23 11:37:00的发言:


你说的有点道理,但并不正确。ETS考察的就是一种准确的思维判断,"批评"和"评论"不同,"扩展评论"应当继续评论,而不是引用他人的观点。在这两方面都有点问题。这些思维是有差异的,或许细小。

一定要注意,这些往往就反映了ETS要考核的重点,必须必须认真对待


十分感谢你不厌其烦的给我解释这个问题!

你的意思是这里的criticism 是批评,而不是评论的意思?  如何这样确认呢? 我查遍longman, webster, 金山词霸, 通通说它有批评和评论两个意思.

是否ETS在这里有何倾向, 我很想知道.

但是我可以肯定的是, 对critique的批评和评论两意思没有倾向, 因为我同时在阅读大全中看到这两种用法.

一定要注意,这些往往就反映了ETS要考核的重点,必须必须认真对待。---------  尽管我很认真的对待, 还是经常搞不懂, 这个就是我痛苦的地方.

"扩展评论"应当继续评论,而不是引用他人的观点。---- 按照答案只好这样解释这题, 但我还是疑惑.请看这一段话:  

由于复杂的原因, 某国发生动乱. 据美联社分析, 动乱的原因是A, B ,和C. 路透社提供了另一种解释, D造成了此动乱. --------- 这难道不是一个评论和评论的扩展么? 我看不一定非得说:

由于复杂的原因, 某国发生动乱. 原因有A, B, 和C.  另外还有D,

6#
发表于 2005-1-28 22:35:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用egretxm在2005-1-26 6:49:00的发言:


十分感谢你不厌其烦的给我解释这个问题!

你的意思是这里的criticism 是批评,而不是评论的意思?  如何这样确认呢? 我查遍longman, webster, 金山词霸, 通通说它有批评和评论两个意思.

是否ETS在这里有何倾向, 我很想知道.

但是我可以肯定的是, 对critique的批评和评论两意思没有倾向, 因为我同时在阅读大全中看到这两种用法.

一定要注意,这些往往就反映了ETS要考核的重点,必须必须认真对待。---------  尽管我很认真的对待, 还是经常搞不懂, 这个就是我痛苦的地方.

"扩展评论"应当继续评论,而不是引用他人的观点。---- 按照答案只好这样解释这题, 但我还是疑惑.请看这一段话:  

由于复杂的原因, 某国发生动乱. 据美联社分析, 动乱的原因是A, B ,和C. 路透社提供了另一种解释, D造成了此动乱. --------- 这难道不是一个评论和评论的扩展么? 我看不一定非得说:

由于复杂的原因, 某国发生动乱. 原因有A, B, 和C.  另外还有D,



啊,我對criticism的意思理解沒有仔細分析.我想,應該如你所說,是有兩種涵義.


但,你舉出的例子並不恰當.因為第一句就是對那些學者的判斷.如果你舉出的例子一開始說,各家通訊社分析不同原因,那就比較貼切了.


請執正


7#
 楼主| 发表于 2005-2-1 12:55:00 | 只看该作者

搞不懂, 我决定马虎一点, 算了!

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

Mark一下! 看一下! 顶楼主! 感谢分享! 快速回复:

手机版|ChaseDream|GMT+8, 2025-1-28 05:56
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号

ChaseDream 论坛

© 2003-2023 ChaseDream.com. All Rights Reserved.

返回顶部