【每日阅读训练第四期——速度越障23系列】【23-14】文哲史_Philosophy of Right

m1nt

SPEED
TIME1 2’38”   Introduction of Philosophy of Right and three spheres of versions of 'right
TIME2 1‘19”   Conception and the relationship among freedom, will and right
TIME3 3’00“   Definition of will
TIME4 1’23”   
TIME5 1’00”

OBSTACLE 5’

JennyF

谢谢jay分享的文章，话说看哲学中文都头大的，2－5的部分，学到一个东西就是 will -> reality, 其他真心都不记得了。。谢谢把原著也搬上来。。

3'00
2'47
3'58
2'55
3'24

9'55 comments of  "Philosophy of Right"
     -> first debate: two extremes, then take the middle position
     -> second debate: the two approaches both can work.
      -> the system of Hegel's work: the "Philosophy of Right" is M to some extent and is non-M to some extent as well, the question is the how much is the extent. The question should be discussed in a specific system

750750

2min25s
2min11s
3min05s

7min23s
作者简述了黑格尔的哲学思想，并且介绍了关于其哲学思想一直存在着两大争议，但是现在黑格尔的思想普遍被哲学家所接受
作者接受了该如何正确理解黑格尔的著作的方法和思想

dericklx4la

感觉obstacles要比speed好懂多了，完全没有信心把speed看第二遍...
2'51''
2'06''
2'45''
2'36''
2'11''
9'00''

Cri倩

1'56" the release time of philosophy of right and the basis and content of philosophy of right
2'11" what "philosophy of right" talks about -- 2 aspects then talks about the science of right and its role in the philosophy
1'58" the details about will (definition, content, forms)
1'42" the role that will plays in the concept
1'50" resolution of will, finite will and the problem of the content
活生生地看得慢不说。。还越看越不懂。。。
5'31” the debate about the political sympathies of the philosophy of right
         the debate about the metaphysics of the philosophy of right
         introduces the system of hegel's work and the author's positive attitude to the system of hegel's work
感觉越障比较好读。。。。

饼干小熊

P1 3‘24
P2 9'24 晕掉了

O 7’48 这个还好

nickychen

谢谢Jay~
哲学...我会再回来读一遍的...先去平复一下心情...
Time 1: 2'47" 401words
Hegel's the philosophy of right begins with a discussion about free will.
The book of Hegel is mainly discussing Hegel's three spheres of versions of "right".

Time 2: 2'17" 317words
peculiar特殊的，罕见的，特权，特有财产
The philosophic science of right has object idea of right. And right is positive in general.

Time 3: 3'35" 410words
Explaning the "I" and "the will"

Time 4: 2'21" 304words
The definite phrases of the will, the content of determinate phrase of will><....

Time 5: 2'59" 327words
caprice任性，反复无常

Time 6: 7'55" 1266words
Two argument on Hegel's Philosophy of Right - totalitarianism or liberalism, metaphysical or non-metaphysical.
The systematic reading of Hegel's work need to view his writings within the a larger systme.

cherryyyy

1-2:37
Brief introduction of Hegel‘s philosophy of right
The philosophy of right begins with a discussion of concept of free.
The bulk of the book is devoted to discussing Hegel’s three spheres version‘s of right.
The conclusion of the book
2-2:22
Introduction of right:
The philosophic science of the right has as its object the idea of right,
The science of right is part of a philosophy.
The right is positive in such general fields.
The territory of right is in general the spiritual.
3-3:26
The will contains indeterminateness
The I is also the transition of indeterminateness to distinct content and object.
Will is the unity of university and individuality
The forms of will: self consciousness
4-2:16
the content of will& the system of content.
5-3:08
Will is unique
The relationship between will and I
Will contains a reflection from everything and a dependence upon content.
However the definition of will has not come to an agreement.
Obstacle: 8:26
---The first debate on Hegel ‘s view: Hegel ‘s views are best viewed as politically moderate, in between the extremes of conservatism and liberalism.
---The second debate on its relationship to metaphysics: Hegel’s views are metaphysical at least in this most basic sense.
---the difference between metaphysical and non-metaphysical
---the sys thematic reading of the Hegel’s work:
   ---the non-metaphysical approach is best understood as a non-systematic reading of Hegel’s work. A non-systematic reading of Hegel’s work views a given piece of Hegel’s writing apart from Hegel’s larger philosophical system
   --- it is important to note some general features of Hegel’s system and its alleged relationship with his Philosophy of Right

pgjason

1'42"
1'35"
1'54"
1'24"
1'28"

5'40"

Thank you, Jay~

rcurly

1.3'27''
the philosophy of right is the most mature one written by Hegel.--> freewill is the core of this book--> three sphere to be a man??or life?..= = three versions of right…

despotism 专制，专政

2.看不下去了。。。感觉满眼都是认得的单词，就是不知道在绕什么。。。哲学太难驾驭了。。。
  

越障
8'25''
Here are two parts.
I. first debate on whether Hegel's view are conservative or liberal.
II. second debate on systematic method of reading Hegel's work, which involved with the metaphysic thinking of his work.