og-4-22

leslie123456789

原文：

The majority of successful senior managers do not
closely follow the classical rational model of first clarifying
goals, assessing the problem, formulating options,
estimating likelihoods of success, making a decision,
(5) and only then taking action to implement the decision.

问题：

22. According to the passage, the classical model of decision analysis includes all of the following EXCEPT
(A) evaluation of a problem
(B) creation of possible solutions to a problem
(C) establishment of clear goals to be reached by the decision
(D) action undertaken in order to discover more information about a problem
(E) comparison of the probable effects of different solutions to a problem

答案是d,但是我觉得它不正好对应着上面红色标记的部分吗？为什么还是不对的呢？请nn指点，谢谢！

almarabbit01

文中是说classical model 是after making decision再做, 而intuitive managers includes taking actions in the process of making decision. 这是他们的不同之处. 你再仔细读一下原文.

leslie123456789

楼上的是不是看错了阿？这是一道举例排除题啊，它问的是classical model，跟inuitive无关。

tulipmontreal

action undertaken in order to discover more information about a problem

这个信息没有

而comparison of the probable effects of different solutions to a problem =estimating likelihoods of success

现在明白了吧? 奇怪我昨天回答了的, 怎么没发布?

leslie123456789

and only then taking action to implement the decision“采取行动补充完善这个决策”不是跟D中的寻找更多关于问题本身的信息一致吗？只有进一步发现了问题的本质，方能使决策更加完善。我是不是砖牛角尖了？

agk99

22. According to the passage, the classical model of decision analysis includes all of the following EXCEPT(細節題，取非，找第三段)

(A) evaluation of a problem (assessing the problem)

(B) creation of possible solutions to a problem (formulating options)

(C) establishment of clear goals to be reached by the decision (clarifying goals)

(D) action undertaken in order to discover more information about a problem

(E) comparison of the probable effects of different solutions to a problem (estimating likelihoods of success)

(取非題就是找講述現代經理人的那一段)

D選項的嚴格來說前半部是對的，但後半部就不對了

至於你的推論，我認為合理，只可惜原文沒這樣說

tulipmontreal

and only then taking action to implement the decision“采取行动补充完善这个决策”不是跟D中的寻找更多关于问题本身的信息一致吗？只有进一步发现了问题的本质，方能使决策更加完善。我是不是砖牛角尖了？
这个只是说采取行动来实现决策制定的目标

leslie123456789

自己记错单词了，implement&complement一个执行一个补充。。。搞混了

谢谢各位，实在不好意思。

活在当下

问题问的是 the classical model of decision analysis，答案D不是具体的分析方式

buddyk

嗯，虽然是因为其它问题引起的这个问题，但这个问题细想还是蛮有趣的：）