一道LSAT题

lawyer_1

一道LSAT题供讨论，等后再公布答案和原因

In a recent poll of chief executive officers(CEOs) of 125 large corporations, the overwhelming majority claimed that employee training and welfare is of the same high priority as customer satisfication. So the popular belief that the top management of large corporations behaves indifferently to the needs and aspirations of employees is unfounded.

The argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it

A)  fails to define adequately the term "top management"

B)  presumes, without giving justification, that one is not indifferent to something that one considers a top priority

C)   presumes, without giving justification, that the CEOs' priorities tend to be misplaced

D)   presumes, without giving justification, that the CEOs' claims are reflected in actual practice

E)  makes a generalization based on an unrepresentative sample

pocahontas

D

文中majority claimed that.. 和belief that ...behaves 分别对应D中的claims和actual practice

B相比下来错在that one is not indifferent to...

leeon

B;

很有意思的一道问题，这要是AA题材的话，E中的sample问题也可以攻击，B打破了原文的reasoning,应该是most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds ；原文的推理说大部分CEO声称员工的培训和福利与客户满意是同等重要的，因此公众相信大公司高管们对员工的需要和渴望举止冷淡是没有理由的。

这里面最严重的逻辑错误应该是将员工的需要和渴望与员工的培训和福利画上了等号。正如B所说对一个人无关紧要的事情被另一个人认为是重要的。

LES

偶选D。

leeon

D是无关选项；

原文所说的CEO们关心employee training and welfare ，而结论中所说的是the needs and aspirations of employees ，这两个有差别。

sweeet

俺选A

wanze

i choose (d)

crazyep

我也觉得是D

mariezhu

tend to vote for B

what's the given answer?

流沙

选B，虽然一开始觉得D很对，甚至是正常思维。但仔细看原文根本没有提及到claim和practice的关系。