华盛顿大学和多伦多大学MBA选哪个好？

VCmedicine

加拿大这几年的MBA扩招挺厉害的(不仅是ROTMAN),我之前看过一篇文章是concordia教授对本地MBA扩招的批评.

因为扩招,G的平均分是大不如前了(就是对比5年前).

上一年CD就有个帖子 G640 CFA HOLDER  5月份报的AD.相对美国TOP 15来说ROTMAN明显要好进.不过这并不能因此而否定ROTMAN的质量.

jlb113311

多伦多因为扩招，今年听说要招500个。。。。。。门槛降低不少，竞争性价比高-- by 会员 jlb113311 (2011/12/12 23:14:18)

Hi, could you please indicate the source of this information?here is a quote from their representative Claire:"Every year we have 100+ waitlisted applications and the average GMAT scores of these waitlisted applicants is around 650. Needless to say, these individuals have very good work experience.  Aforementioned, for the 2012 intake, we plan on adding one more section. Currently in each of our four sections we have 60-65 students. When you do the math, by adding a new section, we will still not be able to accommodate all of the waitlisted applications!" that's the only official information i know of the expansion. it's great if you can provide another piece but please indicate the source as well. since the information provided here may be used in the decision making process of some applicants, it's important to make sure it's accurate and reliable, isn't it? -- by 会员 rotman2014 (2011/12/13 10:03:06)

is the information from 'http://www.google.com.hk/gwt/x?site=universal&q=rotman+mba+2012+increase&hl=zh-CN&ei=7b_mTpi-PMuaiQezZw&ved=0CAwQFjAD&source=m&rd=1&u=http://www.rotman.utoronto.ca/mba/blogs/blogsDetail.aspx?name%3DClaire%2520Gumus%26id%3D33'

TTK

个人觉得rotman，不给钱实在太贵，读不起啊。

rotman2014

多伦多因为扩招，今年听说要招500个。。。。。。门槛降低不少，竞争性价比高-- by 会员 jlb113311 (2011/12/12 23:14:18)

Hi, could you please indicate the source of this information?here is a quote from their representative Claire:"Every year we have 100+ waitlisted applications and the average GMAT scores of these waitlisted applicants is around 650. Needless to say, these individuals have very good work experience.  Aforementioned, for the 2012 intake, we plan on adding one more section. Currently in each of our four sections we have 60-65 students. When you do the math, by adding a new section, we will still not be able to accommodate all of the waitlisted applications!" that's the only official information i know of the expansion. it's great if you can provide another piece but please indicate the source as well. since the information provided here may be used in the decision making process of some applicants, it's important to make sure it's accurate and reliable, isn't it? -- by 会员 rotman2014 (2011/12/13 10:03:06)

is the information from 'http://www.google.com.hk/gwt/x?site=universal&q=rotman+mba+2012+increase&hl=zh-CN&ei=7b_mTpi-PMuaiQezZw&ved=0CAwQFjAD&source=m&rd=1&u=http://www.rotman.utoronto.ca/mba/blogs/blogsDetail.aspx?name%3DClaire%2520Gumus%26id%3D33'

-- by 会员 jlb113311 (2011/12/13 11:11:41)

yes, it is.
the link is http://www.rotman.utoronto.ca/mba/blogs/blogsDetail.aspx?name=Claire Gumus&id=33

jlb113311

加拿大这几年的MBA扩招挺厉害的(不仅是ROTMAN),我之前看过一篇文章是concordia教授对本地MBA扩招的批评.因为扩招,G的平均分是大不如前了(就是对比5年前).上一年CD就有个帖子 G640 CFA HOLDER  5月份报的AD.相对美国TOP 15来说ROTMAN明显要好进.不过这并不能因此而否定ROTMAN的质量.-- by 会员 VCmedicine (2011/12/13 10:57:28)

没人否定r的质量吧？不过rotman blog里里面提到，每年有1000多人申请，今天录取320的话，录取率大概26％左右。不会很高。We had a wonderful information session on Wednesday. As usual it was very well attended and we had a very interactive audience; good questions and it was clear that the prospects in the room did their research well! Our current student Martha Eggengberger shared her experience throughout her first year and her internship with Bain&Company!One of the topics we discussed was around the expansion plan theRotmanSchool is undertaking. Our prospectiveMBAstudents in the room were concerned about the quality of our future student body and how we would maintain the same quality given that we are aiming to add a fifth section.I had to write about this!While we understand your concerns, we have to say these concerns are unneeded. TheRotmanSchool of Management has a very strong reputation world-wide; our rankings demonstrate clearly where we stand. We have no reason to compromise the quality as we receive very strong applications each year; around 1,100 applications for the full-time program, and due to space constraints we regrettably are not able to admit some brilliant individuals into our program.Every year we have 100+ waitlisted applications and the average GMAT scores of these waitlisted applicants is around 650. Needless to say, these individuals have very good work experience.  Aforementioned, for the2012intake, we plan on adding one more section. Currently in each of our four sections we have 60-65 students. When you do the math, by adding a new section, we will still not be able to accommodate all of the waitlisted applications!Why do we need to expand? We need to expand toincreaseour competitiveness. As our former Associate Dean used to say “Scale matters!” When you look at some other international topMBAprograms,Rotmanhas a relatively smaller intake. This means these other top business schools have more alumni representing the school out in the workforce. From recruitment stand point we have seen that employers are more attracted to business schools where they can meet with a large number of strongMBAcandidates. By increasing the intake size,Rotmanwill be able to produce more graduates and attract more global companies. Currently we have around 400 companies recruiting atRotman; we would definitely like to see more employers on campus.

TTK

对了，如果扩招，T不到100申请有戏吗？

jlb113311

个人觉得rotman，不给钱实在太贵，读不起啊。-- by 会员 TTK (2011/12/13 11:28:44)

rotman已经手下留情了。。。。那个mcgill。。。。。。吭爹至极啊。本来魁省移民学费7000，现在一律同等，上升至6万多。。。。。一下子九倍。。。。。

didai1314

个人觉得rotman，不给钱实在太贵，读不起啊。-- by 会员 TTK (2011/12/13 11:28:44)

rotman已经手下留情了。。。。那个mcgill。。。。。。吭爹至极啊。本来魁省移民学费7000，现在一律同等，上升至6万多。。。。。一下子九倍。。。。。

-- by 会员 jlb113311 (2011/12/13 11:36:49)

恩 我也是觉得如果ROTMAN不给钱，太坑了。。。反正我觉得这个学校是俨然太贵。。。你说凭嘛，，，凭嘛
T100，ROTMAN最低要求是多少？ 如果低于最近因该是没戏的，这个不想GMAT和GPA的关系可以互补

Stefaniezhu

总的来说, Rotman, Ivey跟美国20-35名左右的差不多，就是介乎UT Austin和Georgetown之间，当然是大概情况，具体对于个人又不一样了。

个人建议，如果以后目标是Finance，选Rotman，否则Washington

拿到两个offer，多伦多大学和华盛顿大学。

1）排名差不多，多大北美24，华大美国26。
2）多伦多、西雅图两个城市感觉都很宜居，就业机会也都不错。
3）算下来学费和生活费多大比华大贵出18万rmb左右，但是加拿大可以在毕业后直接拿3年工作签证，经济相对来说比较稳定。

犹豫不觉中，请过来人指点！

如果想未来在当地工作和生活的话，还有什么因素需要考虑？哪个学校在这些因素上更有优势？

-- by 会员 沉雁落鱼 (2011/12/12 22:40:47)

TTK

我记得washington 也不大给钱，也属于申的起读不起的那种