Perceptive不是讲语法规则,而是讲what kind of writing and spoken language is right, but both base on the fact (细节题)。Perceptive虽然主要讲spoken和written language,但都是descriptive book中的语法为基础(细节题)
然后举了两个例子,在descriptive书中是错误的,但在perceptive中却是对的
prescriptive会包含有dialect时的语法,但并不一定是语法上应当正确的。
3.作者:虽然有很多很好的manual,但是也有很懂的manual给了bad advice。
有一个例子:讲 standard dialect与nonstandard dialect的区别,并且讲了formal与informal的区别;例子如下(原文中也是这么排版的有变体,排版格式不同!)
4.语法的对错应该由说话人判断。讲语法的书发展趋势应该是base on the fact. (if blabla…, then blablabla)
题目:
1.Descriptive/manual支持哪个(变体多,仔细看题,I done it by myself(nonstandard dialect)和she does as much as me (informal)都是错的,另两个是对的) 我担心,变体会不会是: descriptive支持哪个?选线有 A1,A2,B1,B2啊? perspective(mutual)支持哪个?A1,A2,B1,B2?分别选什么?
混了混了,怎么越看越不明白呢? 不管是D还是P都应该认为 I done it by myself (nonstandard dialect)是错的吧,区别在于D认为 she does as much as me (informal)是对的,而P认为不对吧?至于I do it by myself(standard dialect)与 she does as much as I (formal),D与P都认为是对的
混了混了,怎么越看越不明白呢? 不管是D还是P都应该认为 I done it by myself (nonstandard dialect)是错的吧,区别在于D认为 she does as much as me (informal)是对的,而P认为不对吧?至于I do it by myself(standard dialect)与 she does as much as I (formal),D与P都认为是对的