PREP2-3-Q11

evelyn205205

Ethnohistoric documents from sixteenth-century Mexico
suggesting that weaving and cooking were the most common productive activities for Aztec women may lead modern historians to underestimate the value of women's contributions to Aztec society.Since weaving and cooking occurred mostly (but not entirely) in a domestic setting, modern historians are likely to apply to the Aztec culture the modern Western distinction between "private" and "public" production.Thus, the ethnohistoric record conspires with Western culture to foster the view that women's production was not central to the demographic, economic, and political structures in sixteenth-century Mexico.

A closer examination of Aztec culture indicates that treating Aztec women's production in Mexico in such a manner would be a mistake.Even if the products of women's labor did not circulate beyond the household, such products were essential to population growth.Researchers document a tenfold increase in the population of the valley of Mexico during the previous four centuries, an increase that was crucial to the developing Aztec political economy.Population growth--which could not have occurred in the absence of successful household economy, in which women's work was essential--made possible the large-scale development of labor-intensive chinampa (ridged-field) agriculture in the southern valley of Mexico which, in turn, supported urbanization and political centralization in the Aztec capital.

But the products of women's labor did in fact circulate beyond the household.Aztec women wove cloth, and cloth circulated through the market system, the tribute system, and the redistributive economy of the palaces.Cotton mantles served as a unit of currency in the regional market system.Quantities of woven mantles, loincloths, blouses, and skirts were paid as tribute to local lords and to imperial tax stewards and were distributed to ritual and administrative personnel, craft specialists, warriors, and other faithful servants of the state.In addition, woven articles of clothing served as markers of social status and clothing fulfilled a symbolic function in political negotiation.The cloth that was the product of women's work thus was crucial as a primary means of organizing the flow of goods and services that sustained the Aztec state.

The passage is primarily concerned with

(A) using modern understanding of cultural bias to challenge ethnohistoric documents
(B) evaluating competing descriptions of women's roles in Aztec society
(C) comparing the influence of gender on women's roles in Aztec society and in modern society
(D) remedying a potential misconception about the significance of women's roles in Aztec society
(E) applying new evidence in a reevaluation of ethnohistoric documents

答案是D。
我选的是E，想请问E错在哪儿啊，整篇文章说的是这个documents会引导现代历史学家低估了女性在当时的贡献，作者认为这样的误解是不对的，不是reevaluate么？
谢谢，麻烦各位NN帮我看看这道题啦~

evelyn205205

NN们，麻烦帮我看一下吧~

evelyn205205

NN们，我先在此谢谢各位啦~

glhelr

这个题我觉得需要好好理解一下第一句话~ 作者“reevaluate”的不是document， 因为这个Ethnohistoric documents 本身没有问题，它只是单纯的说"weaving and cooking were the most common productive activities for Aztec women"这么一个事情，有问题的是现在的历史学家们~他们认为纺织和烹饪不重要。作者认为很重要，并说了理由~所以D是正确的， E是不对的哈~

evelyn205205

这个题我觉得需要好好理解一下第一句话~ 作者“reevaluate”的不是document， 因为这个Ethnohistoric documents 本身没有问题，它只是单纯的说"weaving and cooking were the most common productive activities for Aztec women"这么一个事情，有问题的是现在的历史学家们~他们认为纺织和烹饪不重要。作者认为很重要，并说了理由~所以D是正确的， E是不对的哈~

-- by 会员 glhelr (2011/7/15 23:43:24)

恩懂了，谢谢斑竹哦~

lyzlyz1990

glhelr 发表于 2011-7-15 23:43
这个题我觉得需要好好理解一下第一句话~ 作者“reevaluate”的不是document， 因为这个Ethnohistoric docum ...

glhelr 看了你的解释完全清晰了！非常感谢， 我还想在这里直接问你一下这篇文章的Q8
The author of the passage would be most likely to agree with which of the following statements about the documents mentioned in the first sentence of the passage?
(A)        They contain misleading information about the kinds of productive activities Aztec women engaged in.
(B)        They overlook certain crucial activities performed by women in Aztec society.
(C)        They provide useful information about the way that Aztec society viewed women.
(D)        They are of limited value because they were heavily influenced by the bias of those who recorded them.
(E)        They contain information that is likely to be misinterpreted by modern-day readers.
b选项我还是无法理解为什么错，23段一直在说妇女还有其他方面的贡献，所以第一段的document使得现代人产生误解的原因就是因为它不全面，于是作者才需要指出妇女的贡献，也就说明document确实是overlook了certain activities。这样理解可以么？