OG12 137新问 关于动词时态一致，请大家进来看看！！感激不尽!（已解决）

avernus

Joachim Raff and Giacomo Meyerbeer are examples
of the kind of composer who receives popular acclaim
while living, often goes into decline after death, and
never regains popularity again.

(A) often goes into decline after death, and never
regains popularity again
(B) whose reputation declines after death and never
regains its status again
(C) but whose reputation declines after death and
never regains its former status
(D) who declines in reputation after death and who
never regained popularity again
(E) then has declined in reputation after death and
never regained popularity

答案 C
OG关于D的解释The verb tenses are inconsistent with present tense used in the first phrase;redundant again.
我觉得D如果把again去掉以后就是正确的。为什么要求D中的动词(declines, regained)与前面的动词（receives）一致呢？不同时态的动词也可以并列呀？


求各位大哥大姐帮帮忙，谢谢谢谢~~

clumsy123

我脚着在这个句子里三个动词的时态要一致，因为这句话陈述的是一个事实。
就算不是，regained也不对，因为它发生在declines后面，怎么能用过去时呢？

cycyang

为什么要求D中的动词(declines, regained)与前面的动词（receives）一致呢？不同时态的动词也可以并列呀？

我想这三个动词“receive”, "decline", "regain"虽然在结构上是并列关系，但在意思上是有一种承接的，即按照事情可能发生的先后组织语言的。如果 “receive”用的是一般现在时，没有理由regain用过去时
。

avernus

哈哈，‘我脚着’还是蛮搞得。
豁然开朗，谢谢

avernus

谢谢，讲的很清楚，一语中的，‘按照事情可能发生的先后组织语言的’ 我当时还没想到呢，以后还要多多注意才行

fionaz426

按时间顺序叙述比较清晰

小唯唯

同一题，想请问C中后面那个its是怎么指代的呀？？？

avernus

C.   but whose reputation declines after death and
      never regains its former status



its应该指代reputation吧，but后面的从句都是讲reputation怎么样的，如OG解释：
As written, with who as the subject of goes and regains, the last two descriptions illogically continue to refer to the kind of composer.Logically it must be the reputation that declines after the composers death.

小唯唯

C.   but whose reputation declines after death and
      never regains its former status



its应该指代reputation吧，but后面的从句都是讲reputation怎么样的，如OG解释：
As written, with who as the subject of goes and regains, the last two descriptions illogically continue to refer to the kind of composer.Logically it must be the reputation that declines after the composers death.

-- by 会员 avernus (2011/3/23 9:43:03)

荣誉的地位么？？？不是应该是"人"的地位回不到从前了么?

小唯唯

顶起