新prep2 sc2 190

Christianyang

190.(30034-!-item-!-188;#058&004766)(GWD-28-Q24)



Until the passage of the Piracy and Counterfeiting Amendments Act in 1982, a first-time charge of copyright infringement was merely a misdemeanor charge, federal prosecutors being unlikely in pursuing criminal copyright infringers, while offenders were subject to relatively small penalties.

A. charge, federal prosecutors being unlikely in pursuing criminal copyright infringers, while offenders were

B. charge, with federal prosecutors who were unlikely to pursue criminal copyright infringers, offenders being

C. charge, federal prosecutors unlikely to pursue criminal copyright infringers, while offenders were

D. charge; therefore, federal prosecutors were unlikely in pursuing criminal copyright infringers and offenders being

E. charge; therefore, federal prosecutors were unlikely to pursue criminal copyright infringers, and offenders were
此题答案是E 具体讲讲C的错误吧。我认为federal那句是个独立主格，是不是后面的while那里错了？不太确定，同志们讨论下。

Christianyang

顶起

lxw19

感觉“while”又表示转折的含义吧~~而这里federal prosecutors 和offenders之间没有这层含义

还有是不是因为少了therefore，所以本应该表达的因果逻辑关系就模糊了

jbc88

C的错误：1。federal prosecutors unlikely to pursue criminal copyright infringers 不是完整的句子   are unlikely to 还差不多

2。while offenders were 和前面的until 形成一句话的话，就是一句话里2个连词，错吧，也谈不上。感觉似乎挺变扭的。

一点拙见，欢迎拍砖

Christianyang

顶起，群众多讨论啊。

Christianyang

。。。

冷水萧亭

后面那个while要求平行的吧  
C选项while前后明显不平行

Christianyang

后面那个while要求平行的吧  
C选项while前后明显不平行

-- by 会员 冷水萧亭 (2010/9/19 18:59:49)

求具体解答。

luopite

同意第一点的看法，这个句子没谓语的
while这里应该是表转折的连词，所以前后结构应该是对称的
C肯定是错的

C的错误：1。federal prosecutors unlikely to pursue criminal copyright infringers 不是完整的句子   are unlikely to 还差不多

2。while offenders were 和前面的until 形成一句话的话，就是一句话里2个连词，错吧，也谈不上。感觉似乎挺变扭的。

一点拙见，欢迎拍砖

-- by 会员 jbc88 (2010/9/18 21:32:16)

jbc88

后面那个while要求平行的吧  
C选项while前后明显不平行

-- by 会员 冷水萧亭 (2010/9/19 18:59:49)

while也一定要平行吗？
我记得似乎不需要，但是平行更好