再问OG10 第一题

kaipiggy

1.The Wallerstein study indicates that even after a decade young men and women still experience some of the effects of a divorce occurring when a child.

(A)occurring when a child

(B)occurring when children

(C)that occurred when a child

(D)that occurred when they were children

(E)that has occurred as each was a child

答案为D

书上说each don't agree with men and women.

求解释。具体点。谢谢

boboakira

A n+ing 表示正在进行或伴随，divorce明显是他们还在小孩时从父母之类那里经历的，发生在过去，所以必用occured。when a child 主谓全无，是无效碎片fragment，必错
B 同上
C 同上
D that occured 既准确修饰了divorce，又用对了过去时态；主语是young men and women，因此用人称代词指代他们的时候，应该用they （were children）
E has occured 时态错，as 用法错。意思也不通

不知这样能不能帮到你^^

kaipiggy

A n+ing 表示正在进行或伴随，divorce明显是他们还在小孩时从父母之类那里经历的，发生在过去，所以必用occured。when a child 主谓全无，是无效碎片fragment，必错
B 同上
C 同上
D that occured 既准确修饰了divorce，又用对了过去时态；主语是young men and women，因此用人称代词指代他们的时候，应该用they （were children）
E has occured 时态错，as 用法错。意思也不通

不知这样能不能帮到你^^

-- by 会员 boboakira (2010/8/23 18:04:35)

E项的意思不通是怎么个不通法?还有，each用错，为什么呢？是仅仅因为指代错误么？

aaintw

问一下，C如果改成 that occurred when children也是不行吗？不可以看做省略they are吗？

evilleo

C改成that occurred when chileren也不行吧，they are只有和前面的主语一致的时候才能省略的。

aaintw

They 难道不是指代young men and women的吗？