再问2772-63-42

dancerme814

偶的问题是第一题：

Historians sometimes forget that history is continually being made and experienced before it is studied, interpreted, and read. These latter activities have their own history, of course, which may impinge in unexpected ways on public events. It is difficult to predict when “new pasts” will overturn established historical interpretations and change the course of history.

1.     The “new pasts” mentioned in line 6 can best be described as the

(A) occurrence of events extremely similar to past events

(B) history of the activities of studying, interpreting, and reading new historical writing

(C) change in people’s understanding of the past due to more recent historical writing

(D) overturning of established historical interpretations by politically motivated politicians（C）

(E) difficulty of predicting when a given historical interpretation will be overturned

             答案是C无疑问 但始终对B耿耿于怀 不知哪位大侠可以指点迷津？

            xiexie...

xjlv128

就算是B,原文里的read是被动，这里是主动，也不对啊。

排除嘛

amber0919

fftwo

天哪，我无言了。OG11里面的解释及答案与上面的分析似乎差异甚远，看来这文章太有水平了，怎么分析都似乎讲得通，哈哈，不得不佩服出题人。

在OG11里面，这篇文章是REVIEW的第23篇。楼主所问的第一个问题的答案是A（非C也非D），考态度那道题的答案是A（非B）。

不过有一点我肯定同意的，就是这篇文章真的挺难的，我做的时候，六个题目竟然错了三个，我差点晕倒了。后来仔细研读过，还是只感觉懂了一半，也就是还有一半是糊涂的。看来还需要继续努力。

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-7-20 0:53:45编辑过]

happykeeper

结合第6题看的话，似乎og11的答案更合理。

kathy8446

其实我觉得第一题的B不关主被动什么事吧……

主要要表达的应该是C选项的change，至于B的核心词是history，好像不在点子上

michenny

oh,my God终于看懂类比题了,那句话上斜了!

另外也贡献点,1. The “new pasts” mentioned in line 6 can best be described as the

(A) occurrence of events extremely similar to past events

(B) history of the activities of studying, interpreting, and reading new historical writing应为HISTORY

(C) change in people’s understanding of the past due to more recent historical writing

(D) overturning of established historical interpretations by politically motivated politicians（C）

(E) difficulty of predicting when a given historical interpretation will be overturned

B错在LOGIC上，如上,个人觉得。

还有到底那道说DOGMA的应该选什么啊,OG11上答案是D OR A啊?个人目前UP D,有哪里没看清楚吗?请指点哦。

denne

这篇是我心头大恨！！！第一遍全军覆没，第二遍错一半。简直无语了，消沉了快一周。

loomoo

赫赫，偶今天第一遍做此题，6错5，看来还需好好努力~

据说og11上有此题？我去瞅瞅~

ssl507

是的，og第二题答案是A

解释是传统的观点是NOT ONLY部分，而C. Vann Woodward 认为传统的观点不全面，NOT ONLY...,BUT ALSO...