OG12-14 无人问过～～

mboo2005

我问个没人问过的A，A说Over the next ten years，题干里面是within five years，这个时间点不需要对应？

谢谢

blcubeatrice

只是说double the number of movie screens是5年之内。

10年那个是和profit有关。

不矛盾

AlohaDJ

Justifying assumption is a sufficient assumption, in constrast to a necessary assumption.  As such, the justifying assumption can directly lead to the conclusion in the stimulus.

A can accomplish that feat while B cannot since B needs an additional assumption - after the economy is revitalized, people will go to the cinema.  If people go to night clubs instead, the argument falls apart.

-- by 会员 sdcar2010 (2010/12/13 22:02:59)

COOL explanation!

zjsxsj

我是这么认为的，原文说they are predicting solid profi ts both for themselves and for the established cinema operators.即要对investors和established cinema operators都要有好处。
但B的假设成立的话，As distinct from the existing cinemas, most of the cinemas being planned would be located in downtown areas,in hopes of stimulating an economic revitalization of those areas.
也就是说现在的established cinema operators主要是建在非downtown区域，那么新建的电影院在downtown促进了经济发展后，会把部分人流从郊区带到市内，从而对established cinema operators没有好处，也就不符合原文的逻辑了。

rx_11

一年以后碰巧再看到这个题，觉得完全懂了··虽然现在已经不考GMAT了，但是还是想回答一下这个问题，当时这个问题真让我纠结··

其实问题的关键在于they are predicting （1）solid profits both for themselvesand （2）for the established cinema operators.

B只满足（1），而不满足（2）。

（2）这个地方是B为什么错的关键！！所以做CR时要仔细的读题，特别是问题和结论部分。

zibimi

美国的downtown和老百姓住的地方要很远，而老百姓住的地方到downtown的高速路附近就有很多电影院，所以在downtown兴建了，老百姓也不一定乐意去，到了晚上downtown就像个空城一样

littleyya

一年以后碰巧再看到这个题，觉得完全懂了··虽然现在已经不考GMAT了，但是还是想回答一下这个问题，当时这个问题真让我纠结··

其实问题的关键在于they are predicting （1）solid profits both for themselvesand （2）for the established cinema operators.

B只满足（1），而不满足（2）。

（2）这个地方是B为什么错的关键！！所以做CR时要仔细的读题，特别是问题和结论部分。

-- by 会员 rx_11 (2011/9/14 23:31:36)

这个解释最好，全都满足

sdcar2010

This question is not a paradox type of question.

littleyya

那让我再好好看一看。。理解错了了吗。。
继续做题！！

亲亲麦小兜

终于明白了，it raises the question
of whether theaters in a revitalized downtown would draw business away from theaters in other
locations, thus reducing the established cinema operators’ profi ts.

一年以后碰巧再看到这个题，觉得完全懂了··虽然现在已经不考GMAT了，但是还是想回答一下这个问题，当时这个问题真让我纠结··

其实问题的关键在于they are predicting （1）solid profits both for themselvesand （2）for the established cinema operators.

B只满足（1），而不满足（2）。

（2）这个地方是B为什么错的关键！！所以做CR时要仔细的读题，特别是问题和结论部分。

-- by 会员 rx_11 (2011/9/14 23:31:36)