大家觉得Duke和Michigan哪个好

thecow10000

Overall school reputation/prestige:   Duke > Michigan
Undergraduate business school (and banking consulting placement): Ross > Fuqua
Total number of alum: Ross > Fuqua
China: Fuqua > Ross
Weather: Durham, NC > Ann Arbor, MI
Quality of life/geographic location:  Durham = Ann Arbor
B-School:  Fuqua = Ross
Finance Program: Ross > Fuqua
Consulting program: Ross = Fuqua

echo_me

呵呵，ls的比较详细。哈哈

vincelee

感谢大家，特别是携隐前辈的指点！

携隐

Overall school reputation/prestige:   Duke > Michigan
Undergraduate business school (and banking consulting placement): Ross > Fuqua
Total number of alum: Ross > Fuqua
China: Fuqua > Ross
Weather: Durham, NC > Ann Arbor, MI
Quality of life/geographic location:  Durham = Ann Arbor
B-School:  Fuqua = Ross
Finance Program: Ross > Fuqua
Consulting program: Ross = Fuqua

-- by 会员 thecow10000 (2009/12/1 6:29:33)

没听过Fuqua有BBA，难道是我孤陋寡闻。

turbo2008

Fuqua 没有undergraduate business school

thecow10000

You are right. I should have made it more clear.  Ross undergrad BBA vs Duke undergrads placement into consulting/banking.

turbo2008

You are right. I should have made it more clear.  Ross undergrad BBA vs Duke undergrads placement into consulting/banking.

-- by 会员 thecow10000 (2009/12/1 10:18:05)

You are comparing apples to oranges. If you compare Michigan undergrads vs. Duke undergrads (%) placement into consulting/banking Duke will still have the upper hand.

pxn_008

呵呵， 给大家一些新鲜数据把  (经济这么差，看看有哪些忠实雇主）

Top Consulting employment ,2009 (MBA report, full time + intern hires, 我假定大家不是去美国读本科哈）

              Ross:                                       Fuqua:              

McKinsey   19                                             9

Bain            12                                            10

BCG            11                                            13

Other firms

A.T.Kearney  14                                       3

Booz               7                                      N/A

Deloitte         16                                    23

资料来源（ MBA　2009 employment report)

PS: 07,08 年这个数字估计都要翻翻。有兴趣的自己到学校网站查。

pagui

Overall school reputation/prestige:   Duke > Michigan
Undergraduate business school (and banking consulting placement): Ross > Fuqua
Total number of alum: Ross > Fuqua
China: Fuqua > Ross
Weather: Durham, NC > Ann Arbor, MI
Quality of life/geographic location:  Durham = Ann Arbor
B-School:  Fuqua = Ross
Finance Program: Ross > Fuqua
Consulting program: Ross = Fuqua
Health Care:  Fuqua >> Ross
This is important because Healthcare related industry is good shield in this unusual crisis setting, I heard that lot of Fuqua Chinese 10' students find decent internships in Johnson & Johnson(6 offers to Fuqua Chinese 10' students).
Fuqua Ranked top in Health Care program, also, Duke has a top 10 ranked Medical school.

-- by 会员 thecow10000 (2009/12/1 6:29:33)

aspirant2010

恩，又发现一些不同，不过不知道哪些数据对大家有意义。

Ross学费比Duke便宜1万多；
国际学生比例Ross30%，Duke39%;
已婚比例Ross 15%, Duke 28%;
学生来自Asia Ross 17%, Duke 27%;
Living Alumni Ross 26000多，Duke 13000多；
毕业时就业率 两者一样

就业方面内容太多了，就不贴了，大家自己看：
ROSS:
http://www.businessweek.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/michigan.html

DUKE:
http://www.businessweek.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/fuqua.html

两校都差不多，携隐也建议了都申请。大家如果有精力还是都申请吧，Essay题目有些不同但都比较常见。等ad都下来了再比较去哪家