关于本科毕业申请marketing phd

kndx5

kellogg，yale，nyu显然不是top5，columbia最多是第五，而且还是非常有争议的。chicago是最好的，拒了chicago去kellogg真是脑子秀逗了。

benja

回复kndx5

你是按照什么排呢？

cb or quant.?

placement?

or sth eles?

其实排名这个问题原本就是比较无聊的

feimao66

to benja,

What you side is every year. So just tell us the most recent 5 years.
btw, ttf was a graduate student. hehe

phdsucks

agree with kndx5 and Feimao66!

To benja, It is NOT possible for thu and pku undergraduate students to get top 5 offers EVERY YEAR. I am physically in a top marketing phd program and I know it quite well. hehe

benja

to phdsucks

能问下是在哪个学校的program么？

feimao66

hoho, sigh...

robyngates

benja is tai gang ing here. no tolerance for challenging...

kndx5

你告诉我按照哪个标准排kellogg，nyu和yale能排到前5？

kellogg最近几年都招不到新老师，前几年没办法连自己managerial econ面试没通过的人都要了，今年吃了回饺子，招到了song yao，要是没有yuxin chen，他们modeling连一个active的正教授都没有，还top5？

nyu这两年挖了几个人，师资阵容很强大，但是毕竟学校整体水平在那呢，要是把他排到mit，stanford前面，估计nyu自己都得脸红。

yale主要是behavior好，modeling太一般了，前10都没有。

国内能申请到chicago真是太nb了，谁给透露一下，renna jiang今年place到哪里了？

珠宝

UC-Davis

feimao66

我感觉top10应该是：
upenn, chicago, duke, nyu, northwestern, columbia， umich 专业牛
harvard, mit, stanford 综合牛专业稍弱
top11-20
yale, cornell, berkeley, cmu综合牛专业较弱
ucla, unc, maryland, usc, indiana, austin
top21-30
UMN, wustl, psu, rice, florida, wisconsin, tamu, washington, osu, emory
（uiuc, purdue, msu也不错）