逐段批驳!! ---- 美国海归经历：国内和国外生活的真实比较

coco32

总的来说，同意原文的说法。以经验来看，感叹号过多的文章不可靠。

-- by 会员 Lugosi (2008/12/6 12:29:00)

赞成,楼主情绪不稳定,正在高烧中......
楼主太过偏激,而原文理性多了

DL88

The discussion is very interesting. I agree with most of points made by the author. Once you get a job in US, if you put all the benefits, like medical insurance coverage and other life insurance, you can see a huge difference between US and China.

I worked in Shanghai before I came to US, and I made an income falling into the range discussed above. After tax, you took home a very limited amount, and you have to pay all medical expenses, make provision for kid's education and your own pension/retirement savings. I knew everything would be good if you are healthy and young, but we are human beings -we are mortals and we cannot avoid falling ills.

Later I came to US, and got a job after master education. I live in Los Angeles. I understand the money I make here gives more value. One example, here you pay social security tax, but you will be delighted to know when you die now, your family can get $500 a month (before I just work for 1.5 years). In addition, you pay $100/2 weeks, you fully cover your whole family's medical, dental and eye insurance. You do not have to worry about seeing a doctor -every time you have to pay only $20 co-pay for doctor visit.

One additional value for a person living in US is, the relatively low car purchase and maintenance costs. In China, I believe owning a car is still a luxury item, but in most cities in US, it is a necessity.

In all, if you can make a millionaire in China, do not hesitate going back to China and make it happen. If not, second thought whatever you hear about the easy-money-making stories in China - it is very simple, consider how respresentative of the sample against the population yourself may be a member of.

Good luck for those choosing to stay and those choosing to go back.

dnianbo

The discussion is very interesting. I agree with most of points made by the author. Once you get a job in US, if you put all the benefits, like medical insurance coverage and other life insurance, you can see a huge difference between US and China.
I worked in Shanghai before I came to US, and I made an income falling into the range discussed above. After ta
x, you took home a very limited amount, and you have to pay all medical expenses, make provision for kid's education and your own pension/retirement savings. I knew everything would be good if you are healthy and young, but we are human beings -we are mortals and we cannot avoid falling ills.

Later I came to US, and got a job after master education. I live in Los Angeles. I understand the money I make here gives more value. One example, here you pay social security tax, but you will be delighted to know when you die now, your family can get $500 a month (before I just work for 1.5 years). In addition, you pay $100/2 weeks, you fully cover your whole family's medical, dental and eye insurance. You do not have to worry about seeing a doctor -every time you have to pay only $20 co-pay for doctor visit.

One additional value for a person living in US is, the relatively low car purchase and maintenance costs. In China, I believe owning a car is still a luxury item, but in most cities in US, it is a necessity.

In all, if you can make a millionaire in China, do not hesitate going back to China and make it happen. If not, second thought whatever you hear about the easy-money-making stories in China - it is very simple, consider how respresentative of the sample against the population yourself may be a member of.

Good luck for those choosing to stay and those choosing to go back.

-- by 会员 DL88 (2010/4/30 15:44:56)

How long have you not been back to China?  Is car still a luxury item in China?

嘎嘣豆豆

当然不同人有不同的见解，完全尊重LZ的想法。

个人愚见，更多人喜欢美国是出于他们开放包容的心态吧，在美国不觉得自己是外地人/外国人 工资的确不够高，但是那种氛围真喜欢 而且可以说任何自己想说的事情 公司中也比较少的connection之类的潜规则。在中国觉得自己在家啊 而且中国的薪水的确现在很多人不少 但是公司的气氛普遍比较压抑吧

紫色魅影

两位都有各自的道理，自身条件不一样，平台不一样，因此看到的也不一样，没有必要争执太多。前者本身就是精英中的精英，所以在哪都是前途无量，回国可能空间更大，后者就是大多数的小海龟，在哪里都是需要努力打拼才能慢慢站稳脚跟，所以不用太挑词啦

hkjenny

楼上们北上深都买房了吗2008~现在翻好几倍了。幸好我下手早,否则现在就完了。还好我买了三套,最得意的投资。比MBA值。美国那小小几十万美小case·

hkjenny

去哪可以净利润高,哪就好。美国工科肯定好。商和文就不行了。再说,都成外国人了,就没必要和国内比了.国外大城市超高消费,医疗贵,也都未必好。不过,现房价90后够难的。能留美国先呆吧。

hkjenny

DL88 发表于 2010-4-30 15:44
The discussion is very interesting. I agree with most of points made by the author. Once you get a j ...

您啊,错过了炒房期,可惜。
现在几百万太小数了,早买房的早就翻四五倍了。加上货币通胀,您再回来已被运远甩到后列。
车是太小资本了。
您无车在美国能行吗?必需品。
祝您美国混发大财。