大全28套Section III－17 对答案的疑问

jasdesky

Parents who wish to provide a strong foundation for the musical ability of their children should provide them with a good musical education. Since formal instruction is often a part a good musical education, parents who wish to provide this strong foundation need to ensure that their children receive formal instruction.

The reasoning is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it fails to consider that

(A) parents might not be the only source of a child’s musical education

(B) some children might not be interested in receiving a strong foundation for their musical ability

(C) there are many examples of people with formal instruction whose musical ability is poor

(D) formal instruction might not always be a part of a good musical education（D）

(E) some children might become good musicians even if they have not had good musical educations

要想孩子有strong foundation for musical ability à
                家长要提供good musical education

因为formal instruction通常是good musical education 的一部分，所以要给孩子提供这个strong foundation的家长就要确保孩子接受formal instruction

 

C 不是很好的一个有因无果吗，为什么不对呢？

 

C说提供了formal music education，那么根据题目，能得出提供了Good musical education。有music ability必须要有good musical education，但是有了好的good musical education不一定能推出music ability 啊。这个C不是挺好么？

 

D感觉像是在强词夺理，文中已经说了“formal instruction is often a part a good musical education”，他这里说might not always

 

大家怎么看呢？