问几道语法

gilcarnival

The
            Achaemenid
            empire
            of
            Persia reached the Indus Valley in the
            fifth
            century
            B.C.,
            bringing

the Aramaic
                script with
                it,
                from which was derived both northern and
        southern
            Indian alphabets.

(A)
            the
            Aramaic
            script
            with
            it, from which was derived both northern and

(B)
            the
            Aramaic
            script
            with
            it,
            and
            from
            which deriving both the northern and the

(C)
            with
            it
            the
            Aramaic
            script,
            from
            which derive both the northern and the

(D)
            with
            it
            the
            Aramaic
            script,
            from
            which
            derives
            both
            northern
            and

(E)
            with
            it
            the
            Aramaic
            script,
            and
            deriving from it both the northern and

答案选C 但是个人觉得it没有指代对象。。。

还有句子的后半句可以用and so （so解释结果）吗？prep 破解中有一题是后半句选and so ，但是另有一题说这不符合习惯用法

gilcarnival

没人理我 还好我自己参透了 闪~

中场核心

我也想不通,C的derive是哪个东东发出的?前面有复数名词吗?

zyxbull2002

it 指代Indus valley,这个非常明显的，咋会看不出来呢？

AdamHHH

【考點】主動詞一致（Consistency）
        簡潔(Concise)

1)bring A with B 和bring with B A 表達的意思相同

2)在倒裝結構中，動詞動詞的數的形式由動詞動詞後的主詞的形式決定。如ut of sth。 grows a market for...(由a market 決定動詞動詞grows)。

(A) from which 的which 指代it 即The Achaemenid empire ，而從邏輯意思上，which 應該指代
            script。
        根據倒裝結構的要求，was 應該用were

(B) and 錯誤的將bringing 和deriving 平行起來，使得deriving 後面的結構也成為了主句的伴隨副詞，而邏輯上both the northern and the southern Indian alphabets 是從script derive 來的。因此導致邏輯意思錯誤。

(C) 正確，後半部分是倒裝，應該是both the northern and the southern India alphabets derive from the Aramaic script

(D) derives 應該改為用複數形式

(E) 犯了同B 選項相同的邏輯錯誤

※句子結構: The Achaemenid empire of Persia reached…， bringing with it the…

莫老師:S+Vi+adv ph 句型為符合由輕到重的概念故S與adv ph進行倒裝(選項C Both the northern and the...

     為真正主詞為，複數名詞故derive為複數型不加s) [參考OG-11 #116]

詳見本人發表的PP破解威力加強版

yuching730

楼上AdamHHHNN也是来自美X补习班啊???

heyii

那个是倒装呢，因为后面那个from which要尽量靠近修饰对象