一道困扰我的逻辑题！

soff

大家看看应该怎么做，怎么解释这个题的意思？

　41. Raymond Burr played the role of lawyer Perry Mason on television. Burr's death in 1993 prompted a prominent lawyer to say "Although not a lawyer, Mr. Burr strove for such authenticity that we feel as if we lost one of our own." This comment from a prestigious attorney provides appalling evidence that, in the face of television, even some legal professionals are losing their ability to distinguish fiction from reality.

　　The reasoning in the argument is flawed because the argument

　　(A) takes the views of one lawyer to represent the views of all lawyers

　　(B) criticizes the lawyer rather than the lawyer's statement

　　(C) presumes that the lawyer is qualified to evaluate the perFORMance of an actor

　　(D) focuses on a famous actor's portrayal of a lawyer rather than on the usual way in which lawyers are portrayed on television

　　(E) ignores the part of the lawyer's remark that indicates an awareness of the difference between reality and fiction

cgaboyma

I think E is right.

soff

能解释一下为什么选E吗？我觉得选选A 啊，以一个人的观点代表所有人，我觉得这是推理错误阿

skyzhang

to say "Although not a lawyer, Mr. Burr strove for such authenticity that we feel as if we lost one of our own."

说明人家意识到了这个人不是真的lawyer

This comment from a prestigious attorney provides appalling evidence that, in the face of television, even some legal professionals are losing their ability to distinguish fiction from reality.

题目中说“代表了一些职业人士”

但是 A里面说 takes the views of one lawyer to represent the views of all lawyers

soff

以下是引用skyzhang在2007-5-16 16:46:00的发言：

to say "Although not a lawyer, Mr. Burr strove for such authenticity that we feel as if we lost one of our own."

说明人家意识到了这个人不是真的lawyer

This comment from a prestigious attorney provides appalling evidence that, in the face of television, even some legal professionals are losing their ability to distinguish fiction from reality.

题目中说“代表了一些职业人士”

但是 A里面说 takes the views of one lawyer to represent the views of all lawyers

还是不明白E是什么意思，能不能帮我翻译过来？多谢

skyzhang

(E) ignores the part of the lawyer's remark that indicates an awareness of the difference between reality and fiction

忽略了这个律师的言论中的一部分，这个部分表明了（律师自己）意识到了现实和虚构的区别。

就是说他忽略了那个律师已经说了自己知道这是个电视节目，那个人只是在演戏，不是真的律师。

soff

以下是引用skyzhang在2007-5-16 16:56:00的发言：

(E) ignores the part of the lawyer's remark that indicates an awareness of the difference between reality and fiction

忽略了这个律师的言论中的一部分，这个部分表明了（律师自己）意识到了现实和虚构的区别。

就是说他忽略了那个律师已经说了自己知道这是个电视节目，那个人只是在演戏，不是真的律师。

多谢，比前面理解了点

asupls

PM said "as if", which indicated he knows that RB is not a real lawyer