求教GWD29-Q5 and Q6

care2909

. GWD29-Q5:

The passage suggests that after conducting the research mentioned in line 18, but not before, Robertson would have agreed with which of the following about women’s status and authority in Ghana?

                       

1. Greater land rights and greater involvement in trade made women in precolonial Ghana less dependent on men than were European women at that time.

1. Colonialism had a greater impact on the status and authority of Ghanaian women than on Kenyan women.

2. Colonialism had less of an impact on the status and authority of Ghanaian women that it had on the status and authority of other African women.
           
3. The relative independence of Ghanaian women prior to colonialism was unique in Africa.
           
4. Before colonialism, the status and authority of Ghanaian women was similar to that of Kenyan women.

A为什么不对啊？

care2909

顶！不要沉

whismanc

thx

skigorush

jingjing6688

顶~~~第五题A选项怎么错了?B感觉说反了啊,    Colonialism had a greater impact on the status and authority of Ghanaian women than on Kenyan women.我觉得
            Colonialism 带来的是gender>age,而Ghanaian women 相比较Kenyan women是age更重要，所以应该是Kenyan women受的影响更大阿，到底哪里出了问题？

没办法1987

第一段：原来发现在pre-殖民地时期age比gender，在全部非洲地区，是“殖民地”使得更看重gender

第二段：发现太概括化了。在K地区的pre-殖民地时期gender就很重要

G地：Colonialism
            的前后有很大改变，以前age比gender重要，以后gender重要

K地：Colonialism
            以前gender就很重要

问题问：调查K地以后改变的想法

Colonialism 对G的影响比K更严重，选B

问题问的是：想法的改变

我觉得A无关吧...虽然文中提到了

没办法1987

文章主要讲，CR小同学是怎样修正自己的观点的

文章关键点在“改变”，出题点啊出题点

4、5两题都是围绕着改变在出题，第四题是改变前，第五题是改变以后

chasedreamho

A 的比较感觉有问题 greater involvement 等很明显C和K这两个地方比较的结果，没有europe什么事情，europe 只是在结果上跟K一样，比C惨，但原因不是这个greater involvement 什么的造成的，不过感觉这题很有问题，满怪的，大家讨论吧

zhaoruihan

关于GWD29 Q5
先理顺一下文章结构框架：
进行调查之前---before 殖民     age>gender 在G 与 全部Africa
                        British 殖民      从此gender变成defining characteristic
------------------------------------------------进行调查------------------------------------------------------------------
调查的发现：
before殖民               gender更salient in K than in G [尽管age still crutial]
G地区                       gender 不重要
K地区                       gender 很重要----------这一发现与调查前的认识一致[即“从此，gender成了defining characteristic]

thus, 小R就revise假设，revise之后认为：age superseded gender to varying degrees
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
对比调查前后的观点可以看出：
K地在殖民前后都是gender重要
G地在殖民前是age 〉gender
因此，殖民对于G地的影响大，

zinniz

The passage suggests that after conducting the research mentioned in line 18, but not before, Robertson would have agreed with which of the following about women’s status and authority in Ghana?

A. Greater land rights and greater involvement in trade made women in precolonial Ghana less dependent on men than were European women at that time.   K和欧洲女人一样，G比K高，推出K比G高，但这个之前也是这么认为的！！

B. Colonialism had a greater impact on the status and authority of Ghanaian women than on Kenyan women.

这个要这样理解。因为G地在殖民地之前女人地位很高的，而K地已经显示出女人地位不高了。而殖民地带来的影响就是让女人地位降低，突出男人。所以殖民地化之后，G地的女人通通没地位了，K地的女人本来有一部分就没地位了，只不过是那些年纪大的没地位，所以G地在殖民地之后受到的影响要大。而R这个人之前认为非洲都是一样的，所以殖民地之后对K和G的影响也是一样的。所以前后观点不一致！正确！

C. Colonialism had less of an impact on the status and authority of Ghanaian women that it had on the status and authority of other African women. 过去和现在都不这样认为

D. The relative independence of Ghanaian women prior to colonialism was unique in Africa.  K是一个unique的地方，不是G

E. Before colonialism, the status and authority of Ghanaian women was similar to that of Kenyan women. 反，要高