我在“白勇解题思路”上产生的困惑

mattus

我是在做完OG11的语法之后回头来看白勇的，他的主要思路就是必杀术，几步戳穿GMAC的诡计，比较简单明了，但是他总会说的一句话：“不能改变原句合理重心”叫我非常困惑。

在没有做出最后的答案之前，何从谈起原句呢？在自己不能找到最终答案之前，何谓原句呢？这不是一种自我矛盾的描述么？可能是白勇大侠太超脱了？谁能帮我解答一下呢？

举例：白勇GMAT语法全解中第二章30题

30, The extraordinary diary of William Lyon Machernzie King, prime minister of Canada for over twenty years, revealed that this most bland and circumspect of men was a mystic guided in both public and private life by omens, messages received at seances, and signs for heaven.

A, that this most bland and circumspect of men was a mystic guided in both public and

B, that this most bland and circumspect of men was a mystic and also guided both in public as well as

C, this most bland and circumspect of men was a mystic and that he was guided in both public and

D, this most bland and circumspect of men was a mystic and that he was guided in both public as well as

E, this most bland and circumspect of men to have been a mystic and that he guided himself both in public as well as

按照大侠的必杀：

第一步：宾语从句的连词that不能省略，排除CDE

第二步：习惯用法 both ... as well as...不符合习惯搭配，应使用both...and...排除BDE

补遗：不能改变原句的合理重心

原句guided作为-ed分词修饰a mystic，B选项guided 作为动词与was并列，CDE选项，宾语从句并列was guided/guided成为宾语从句谓语动词，BCDE这四个选项把原句中的从属成分变为并列成分，改变原句合理重心。

正确选项是A

上述红字就是白勇关于句子重心的解释，虽然最后确认A为正确选项之后可以通过句意判断guided表伴随，但是在正确答案没有确定之前，和从谈起“原句”呢？请大家帮忙解答一下这其中的思路，谢谢了

 

mattus

刚才又看到了关于“原句”的解释突然感悟到：就算选项A不一定是正确的选项，但是他所突出的语句重心在后面四个选项是必须遵从一致的。不知道可不可以这么理解～有待验证

遥远的绿洲

可以这么理解,但是这个规律不是绝对的,可以参考着使用

pumpkin

忘记谁说过，说这个是最。。。空泛没有作用的一条

mattus

谢谢了，因为这种方法本身就存在着逻辑缺陷，所以还是尽量回避了，呵呵～希望除此以外，白侠的理论没有歪曲GMAC的出题原则。因为他文中充斥太多的绝对错绝对错，叫我内心很鼓舞很欣喜的同时又不得不谨慎的考虑“绝对”二字的真实性和实际GMAT中的权重～

mygk

正确，是这样的