HKUST VS OXFORD

newboyss

The big three academic journals in accounting are:

Accounting Review, Journal of Accounting Research and Journal of Accounting and Economics

Let's examine the first faculty, F Anderson-Gough, She has no top publications

Anderson-Gough, F, Grey, C & Robson, K (2005) “ ‘It’s a case of helping them to forget that you’re actually a woman’: the Organizational Embedding of Gender Relations in Public Audit Firms” Accounting, Organizations and Society Vol 30, No 5, pp 469-490

Silvester, J, Anderson-Gough, FM, Anderson, NR & Mohamed, AR (2002) “Locus of Control, Attributions and Impression Management in the Selection Interview” Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, Vol 75,  pp 59-76

Anderson-Gough, F, Grey, C & Robson, K (2002) “Accounting professionals and the accounting profession: linking conduct and context”, Accounting and Business Research, Vol 32, No 1, pp 41-56

Anderson-Gough, F, Grey, C & Robson, K (2001) “Tests of time: organizational time-reckoning and the making of accountants in two multi-national accounting firms”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 26, No 2, pp 99-122

Anderson-Gough, F, Grey, C & Robson, K (2000) “In the Name of the Client: the Service Ethic in Two International Accounting Firms”, Human Relations, Vol 53, No 9, pp 1151-1174

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-3-13 22:47:58编辑过]

newboyss

Now we examine the next faculty

Chris Chapman University Reader in Accounting, Fellow of Linacre College
	Read more

Ahrens, T, & Chapman, CS, (2007) 'Management Accounting as Practice', Accounting, Organizations & Society, 32(1/2) 

Ahrens, T, & Chapman, CS, (2006) 'Doing Qualitative Field Research in Management Accounting: Positioning data to contribute to theory', Accounting, Organizations & Society, 31 (8), 819-841

Empson, L, & Chapman, CS (2006). Partnership versus corporation:  Implications of alternative forms of governance for managerial authority and organizational priorities in professional service firms. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 24, 145-176

Chapman, CS, 'Not because they are new: On developing the significance of ERP for MCS research', Accounting, Organizations and Society 30:7-8, pp.685-689, 2005. - Introduction to Themed Section on ERP.

Ahrens, T, & Chapman, CS, 'Accounting for flexibility and efficiency: A field study of management control systems in a restaurant chain', Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol 21:2, 271-301, 2004.

Ahrens, T, & Chapman, C, 'The structuration of legitimate performance measures and management: Day-to-day contests of accountability in a UK restaurant chain', Management Accounting Research, Vol13:2, 2002, pp 1-21.

Ahrens, T, Chapman, C, 'Occupational identity of management accountants in Britain and Germany', European Accounting Review, Vol 9:4, 2000, pp477-498.

Chapman, C, 'Accountants in Organisational Networks', Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 23:8, 1998, pp 737-766.

Chapman, C, 'Reflections on a Contingent View of Accounting', Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 22:2, 1997, pp 189-205.

He has one A- in Contemporary Accounting Research

newboyss

Neils Dechow

Dechow, N & Mouritsen, J (2005): "The Quest for Integration, Management Control and Enterprise Resource Planning Systems". Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 30, Issue 7-8

Dechow, N, 'Enterprise Resource Planning – brugernes erfaringer med at balancere mennesker, processer og teknologi!', Informatik & Økonomistyring, Vol 2002/3:4, 2003, pp 415-465.

Dechow, N, 'ERP systems implementations – en variation over temaet projektstyring?', Informatik & Økonomistyring, Vol 2002/3:1, 2002, pp 47-73.

Dechow, N (2001): “Enterprise Resource Planning Systems – En informations- & ledelsesteknologi?" Informatik &
        Økonomistyring, No 5, pp 441- 461, July 2002.  (published in Danish)

newboyss

 “Creating a Community: The Establishment and Development of the European Accounting Association”. European Accounting Review, Vol 11, No 1 (2002), pp 33-41

“If Only There Were Simple Solutions, But There Aren’t: Some Reflections on Zimmerman’s Critique of Ittner and Larcker”, European Accounting Review, Vol 4, No 4 (2002)

Hopwood, A, 'Understanding Financial Accounting Practice', Accounting, Organisations and Society, Vol 25:8, 2000, pp 763-766.

Hopwood, A, 'Exploring the Modern Audit Firm: an introduction', Accounting, Organisations and Society, Vol 23:5/6, 1998, pp 515-516.

Professor, A. Hopwood,

Hopwood, A, 'Looking Across Rather than Up and Down: On the Need to Explore the Lateral Processing of Information', Accounting, Organisations and Society, Vol 21: 6, 1996, pp 589-590.

Hopwood, A, 'Accounting and Everyday Life: An Introduction', Accounting, Organisations and Society, Vol 19:3, 1994, pp 299.

Hopwood, A, 'Reflections on the Harmonization of Accounting in the European Union', European Accounting Review, 1994.

Hopwood, A, 'Accounting Calculation and the Shifting Sphere of the Economy', European Accounting Review, 1992.

newboyss

P. Quattrone,

Quattrone, P & Hopper, T (2006), "What is IT? SAP, Accounting, and Visibility in a Multinational Organisation", Information and Organization, 16, pp 212-250.

Quattrone, P (2006), 'The Possibility of the Testimony. A Case for Case Study Research', a special essay for the Connexions section of Organization, 13, 1, pp 143-157.

Dagnino, GB, Quattrone, P (2006), 'Management and Business Research Italian Style: The Methodological Contribution of Economia Aziendale to Business Economics', Journal of Management History, 12, 1, pp 36-52.

Quattrone, P, Hopper, T (2005), 'A 'Time-Space Odyssey': Management Control Systems in Multinational Organisations', Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 30, No 7-8, pp 735-764.

Quattrone, P (2005), 'Is Time Spent, Passed or Counted? The Missing Link between Time and Accounting History', Accounting Historians Journal Vol 32, No. 1 June, pp 185-208.

Quattrone, P (2004), 'Accounting for God. Accounting and Accountability Practices in the Society of Jesus (Italy, 16th-17th centuries)', Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol 29:7, pp 647-683.

Quattrone, P (2004), 'Commenting on a commentary? Methodological Choices in Accounting Research', Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol 15:2, pp 232-247.

Jones, G, McLean, C & Quattrone, P (2004), 'Spacing and Timing', Organization, Vol 11, 6, pp 723-741.

Quattrone, P & Hopper, T (2001), 'What does Organisational Change Mean? Speculations on a Taken for Granted Category', Management Accounting Research, Vol 12:4.

Quattrone, P (2000), 'Constructivism and Accounting Research: Towards a Trans-Disciplinary Perspective', Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol 13:2.

newboyss

Suzuki, T. (2003a) The Accounting Figuration of Business Statistics as a Foundation for the Spread of Economic Ideas. Accounting Organizations and Society. Vol. 28. No. 1, pp.65.- 95.

Suzuki, T. (2003b) The Epistemology of Macroeconomic Reality: The Keynesian Revolution from an Accounting Point of View. Accounting Organizations and Society. Vol. 28. No. 5, pp. 471-517. Popular Article

Suzuki, T. (2007 Available at Science Direct) Accountics: Impacts of Internationally Standardized Accounting on the Japanese Socio-Economy. Accounting Organizations and Society. Vol. 32. No. 3, pp. 263-301. 
        New

Suzuki, T. (2007 In Print Available at Science Direct) A History of Japanese Accounting Reforms as a Microfoundation of the Democratic Socio-Economy: Accountings Part II. Accounting Organizations and Society. New

Suzuki, T. & Biondi, Y. (Forthcoming 2007) Accounting and Economics: Unexplored Impacts of IAS / IFRS on Socio-Economy. Introduction to the special edition of Socio-Economic Review October, 2007.

newboyss

Summary:

From the whole department, there is only one paper published in Contemporary Accounting Research which is viewed as the number 4 journal in accounting.

conclusion: None of the faculties in Oxford accounting group will qualify for even an assistant Professor job in HKUST. I may be harsh,but this is a fact. You can contact the faculty office at HKUST if you want to.

mohamoha

god, you must be a PHD student.

but considering the issue outside of academic, I think both r equal.

newboyss

Outside of academia, it is hard to say. London is a financial center and Oxford is a better University overall. However, the placement from HKUST is better than Oxford.

In london, the real good business school is LBS and I admit that LBS is better than HKUST. Oxford and Cambridge are not serious business schools. They are not contenders.

newboyss

I have been in Cambridge before and I like the campus there. i suppose that Oxford should be similar. However, we are talking about whether it is a good business schools or not. If I want to get a bachelor degree, of course i would pick these two. however, for MBAs, noooooooo!