[求助]请教LSAT14-4-7

madcat

7.     Murray: You claim Senator Brandon has accepted gifts from lobbyists. You are wrong to make this criticism. That it is motivated by personal dislike is shown by the fact that you deliberately avoid criticizing other politicians who have done what you accuse Senator Brandon of doing.

Jane: You are right that I dislike Senator Brandon, but just because I have not criticized the same failing in others doesn’t mean you can excuse the senator’s offense.

If Murray and Jane are both sincere in what they say, then it can properly be concluded that they agree that

(A) Senator Brandon has accepted gifts from lobbyists

(B) it is wrong for politicians to accept gifts from lobbyists

(C) Jane’s criticism of Senator Brandon is motivated only by personal dislike

(D) Senator Brandon should be criticized for accepting gifts from lobbyists（E）

(E) one or more politicians have accepted gifts from lobbyists

答案是E, 为什么A 不对呢？

ssssss

the qustion stem ask what they agree at: 

(A) Senator Brandon has accepted gifts from lobbyists

Jane agree with it that Senator Brandon has accepted gifts from lobbyists

however, Murray did not agree he state that jane is wrong to make this criticism.

So , A is wrong.

(B) it is wrong for politicians to accept gifts from lobbyists

this anwear is off the topic, jane and murray are not talkin about weather it is right or wrong for politicians to accept gifts from lobbyists

(C) Jane’s criticism of Senator Brandon is motivated only by personal dislike

jane disagree but murray agree with this answear

(D) Senator Brandon should be criticized for accepting gifts from lobbyists

jane and murray disagree on this.

(E) one or more politicians have accepted gifts from lobbyists

this is what they really agree with, you can read it from the context of conversation