GWD32-Q11

Jenny916

Honey made from such nectar can cause the Effects 引起的中毒

ruoqingwu

    我觉得B答案和D答案都对。
B答案说中毒现象只发生在有这两种花的地方；D答案说中毒现象只发生在这两种花开的季节。从支持原文结论的角度来说，这两种解释是对等的（可以完全互换的）。
大家怎么想？

ruoqingwu

    补充一句，两个答案的一个本质区别是B答案没有用到原文春天开花这个条件，而D答案用到了这个条件，但这并不表示D答案就更好。

aegean040

GWD32-Q11

Several ancient Greek texts provide accounts of people being poisoned by honey that texts suggest was made from the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants. Honey made from such nectar can cause the effects the texts describe, but only if eaten fresh, since the honey loses its toxicity within a few weeks of being made. In Greece, rhododendrons and oleander bloom only in springtime, when they are the predominant sources of nectar.

 

 

Which of the following, if true, most strongly support the accounts of Greek texts?

A.      There are no plants that Greece in ancient times that produce more nectar than rhododendrons or oleanders does.

B.       In areas where neither rhododendrons nor oleanders grow, honey is never poisonous.

C.      A beebive’s honeycomb cannot have some sections that contain toxic honey and other sections that contain nontoxic honey

D.      The incidents of honey poisoning that are related in the ancient texts occurred in the springtime or in the early
    summer

E.       Whether the honey in a beehive is toxic depends solely on which plants
    were the source of that was used to make the honey.

TN24里补出了问题，我觉得应该是D。

A compare with other plants, irrelevant

C different sections of honeycomb, irrelevant

D both springtime and early summer->support, springtime+the honey loses its toxicity within a few weeks of being made

E irrelevant.

B no rhododendrons or oleanders grow,no poisonous honey->原文的逆命题，不能support

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-6-16 16:04:17编辑过]

lichabrend

up

Sophia0703

是support 题

Which of the following, if true, most strongly support the accounts of Greek texts?

kevintown

Which of the following, if true, most strongly support the accounts of Greek texts?

我认为D有严重缺陷啊，即使是在春天中毒，那也有可能是别的花的毒啊，春天大部分花都开嘛，这是无法排除的。

B则说灭有这2种花的地方，蜂蜜就不会中毒，那肯定是这2个花啊。

问的是如何support 这些greek texts，就是说这2个花有毒啊，而非后人发现的开花时间这个事实。

Several ancient Greek texts provide accounts of people being poisoned by honey that texts suggest was made from the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants.

amorela

ding .

amorela

ding .

Mars861227

ffice:smarttags">ffice:smarttags">ffice:smarttags">ffice:smarttags">
    

Several ancient
Greek texts provide accounts of people being
poisoned by honey that texts suggest was made
from the nectar of rhododendron or oleander plants. Honey made from such nectar
can cause the effects the texts describe, but only if eaten fresh, since the
honey loses its toxicity within a few weeks of being made. In Greece,
rhododendrons and oleander bloom only in springtime, when they are the
predominant sources of nectar.

    

 

    

Which of the
following, if true, most strongly support the accounts
of Greek texts?

    

 

    

A.     
There are no plants that Greece
in ancient times that produce more nectar than rhododendrons or oleanders does.

    

B.      
In areas where neither rhododendrons nor oleanders grow, honey is never
poisonous.

    

C.     
A beebive’s honeycomb cannot have some sections that contain toxic honey
and other sections that contain nontoxic honey

    

D.     
The incidents of honey poisoning that are related in the ancient texts
occurred in the springtime or in the early summer

    

E.      
Whether the honey in a beehive is toxic depends solely on which plants
were the source of that was used to make the honey.

    

 

    

应该是B，D虽然在逻辑上没错，但问的是support the accounts of Greek text，所以只能根据题中的信息（红色标记）答题。