[求助]og11-16-88题

weiweier

            However, since these contexts have changed over time, Duverger's approach has proved more durable than his actual findings.  In addition, Duverger's discussion of his findings was hampered by his failure to consider certain specific factors important to women's electoral participation at the time he collected his data: the influence of political regimes, the effects of economic factors, and the ramifications of political and social relations between women and men.

88.        The author implies that Duverger^'s actual findings are

(A)        limited because they focus on only four countries

(B)        inaccurate in their description of the four countries in the early 1950's

(C)       out-of-date in that they are inapplicable in the four countries today

(D)       flawed because they are based on unsound data

(E)        biased by Duverger's political beliefs

答案选C（从文中红色那句推出），但是我觉得B也是对的，可以从黄色那句推出的，既然Duverger's discussion of his findings was hampered因为他没考虑若干factors,说明他的findings是有缺陷的，那么描述肯定是inaccurate。为什么og说B不对呢？           

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-8-29 11:04:32编辑过]

ecochem

我查了一下OG11答案应该是C呀

ecochem

从红色画线部分应该得出C而不是A

因为contexts changed over time,所以out of date!

对于B，原文说discussion被有些因素没考虑到而影响，但是原文没有说finding是inaccurate的

所以B显然不正确

weiweier

以下是引用ecochem在2006-8-29 10:05:00的发言：

我查了一下OG11答案应该是C呀

不好意思啊，匆匆忙忙的都弄错了

weiweier

以下是引用ecochem在2006-8-29 10:11:00的发言：

从红色画线部分应该得出C而不是A

因为contexts changed over time,所以out of date!

对于B，原文说discussion被有些因素没考虑到而影响，但是原文没有说finding是inaccurate的

所以B显然不正确

非常谢谢指点阿，这下明白了，原来是我把discussion和findings搞混了

喵喵猫

我的理解:

黄色那句说的是D的Discussion of findings被hamper了,而不是他的actual findings,他的findings应该往前找"since these contexts have changed over time",说明这四个国家的背景,情况是变化不断的,所以说他的finding过时了。