TTGWD26-18想不通,想不明白啊啊啊啊啊啊

eileenmu木

以下是引用LOUI1121在2007-1-22 16:32:00的发言：

ＥＸＴＡＮＴ这个词在这里很重要．注意第一句话中说＂A medieval manuscript called L contains all eighteen extant tragedies

by the Greek playwright Euripide" . 说明除了L以外没有别的EXTANT MEDIEVAL MANUSCRIPT了, 而Euripides’ Electra 在L中没有COMMENTARY, 所以在所有EXTANT MEDIEVAL MANUSCRIPT都没有.

Ｅ选项＂Euripides’ Electra does not appear accompanied by a com-

mentary in any extant medieval manuscript.＂

希望对你有帮助.

mentary in any extant medieval manuscript.＂

希望对你有帮助.

mentary in any extant medieval manuscript.＂

希望对你有帮助.

懂了

vivianmickey

D错

文章说Of these, ten called the “select plays,” are accompanied in L by ancient commentaries and also

appear in other medieval manuscripts.

在其他手稿中有10个悲剧，而不是有注释。出现在手稿中的是ten而不是commentaries注释。

Seraph1980

同感，E也不对，本题没有正确答案，题目本身不严密。

MarilynR

以下是引用allright在2008-1-29 16:06:00的发言：

答案显然是E

理由：
1.根据题目所述，Electra只出现在手稿L中，因为只有精选的10部才在其他手稿里出现过
2.Electra在L中没有注释
 
所以说，Electra在任何一本现存的中世纪手稿中都是没有注释的，如果E选项没有加“现存”二字就不能选了，因为谁也不知道已经不存在的手稿里有什么

文章只是讲了精选的10部在其他手稿里也出现过，没有交待另外8部有没有在其他手稿出现，--->不能推出Electra只出现在手稿L中

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-6-13 16:13:36编辑过]

sailing2jp

*Of these, ten .... appear in other medieval manuscripts* 这句话排除了其他8本在其他手稿中出现的可能（如果也出现的话，就不是ten了）。

夜凉如水

UP了再看帖子

12再战

顶上去

won872

“A medieval manuscript called L contains all eighteen extant tragedies …… ten called the “select plays,” are accompanied in L by ancient commentaries and also

appear in other medieval manuscripts” “ancient”---old or past--- infers that the commentary were arising from other extant manuscript, not written by the author of L. Ten of them, along with their commentary, must appear in at least one of other extant manuscripts.

 

Conclusion: If Electra does not have commentary in L, it must follow that all other extant manuscript do not contain any of its commentary.

 

C is incorrect “ no commentary is written about Electra in ancient time.” ancient time is too broad defined, medieval manuscript up to the point of L is only a small fraction of it. How do you know, no one after that time point has written any commentary about the play.

Derek2008

如果按SALINATAKI的说法，也可以选A， 因为在现存的手稿中，只有最好的10部有注释，其他8部没有，而这其他8部又没有出现在其他手稿中。

skigorush