请教feifei逻辑-121题

candypolo

121. Observatory director: Some say that funding the mega telescope will benefit only the astronomers who will work with it. This dangerous point of view, applied to the work of Maxwell, Newton, or Einstein, would have satisfied their research and deprived the world of beneficial applications, such as the development of radio, that followed from that research.

 

 

If the statements above are put forward as an argument in favor of development of the mega telescope, which one of the following is the strongest criticism of that argument?

 

 

A.        It appeals to the authority of experts who cannot have known all the issues involved in construction of the megatelescope.

B.        It does not identify those opposed to development of the megatelescope.

C.        It launches a personal attack on opponents of the megatelescope by accusing them of having a dangerous point of view.

D.       It does not distinguish between the economic and the intellectual senses of “benefit”.

E.        It does not show that the proposed mega telescope research is worthy of comparison with that of eminent scientists in its potential for applications.

 

 

可否讲讲题干的意思，选项也不明白，请教nn们！

fredshen

Are you sure you posted the whole question. I remember it was longer than this.

The stem is saying there are some people (opponents) of telescope program saying it can only benifit astronomers(not the public). Then it 上纲上线 to apply this view to the work of famous discovers.  

Basically the flaw is false comparison. There could many  more different aspects between mega telescope program and Maxwell, etc's program that resulted in their discoveries. Maybe indeed, the telescope program really will not benifit the public 

kingme

The question does not seem to make sense (maybe not complete). I think E.