GWD21-7 似乎没人问过

maomm

up

rainforest

C确实正确。但是如C所言，owner of capital 没有拿到相应比例的income, 那么worker岂不是拿到了高于其相应贡献比例的income? 这样E选项岂不是也正确了？那位牛牛说说。这可是本月jj题。

难道因为E中的the value of their labor不等于their contribution to total output。

太晚

E错哪里？E虽然和现实有差距，但加上劳动价值论的假设还是符合作者本意的。其他选项未必有这么好吧？

白流苏

up

AnyaAnya

同问~~~ 为什么E不对~~~

文章不就是说capital被低估了，labor被高估了吗？

请求NN解答

vivian128

/

abby666666

同问。E为什么不对？

加菲猫猫

Let me try to explain.

The argument talks about "contribution (to the total output)" and "income (raised from the total output)".
contribution - 1/3 from capital goods, implies that 2/3 from worker labor
income - 2/3 to wages of workers, 1/3 to the shareholder etc.

From the above, we may conclude that C is correct.

Option E, it sounds correct at first glance. Nevertheless, it mentions that "Workers receive a share of this income that is greater than the value of their labor", which means this sentence claims that "income" is greater than "value of their labor". We cannot draw such a conclusion from the context because the author doesn't imply that the income raised from total output is well worth of the money.