og 194 （同位语）

JerryGuan

我认为：one of whom 是 非限定性定语从句

axbycd

if one of choice is "one of them ", is that correct?  Thanks

蓝色泡泡

我理解 one of whom is blind -->是同位结构 .whom是前面presenters的同位.

而one of them blind 应该是个名词+形容词的独立主格结构吧?

我这样理解对吗? 谢谢指点.

严重同意!!

axbycd

Can we say" presenters at the seminar, one of whom is blind, will....."?

Thanks

心晴

以下是引用axbycd在2004-6-7 13:52:00的发言：
if one of choice is "one of them ", is that correct?  Thanks

同问？

tianwan

no, "one of them" is a subject of a coordinate clause, while "one of whom" is a subject of a type of subcoordinate clause, relative clause. A coordinate conjunction such as "and" is indispensable in front of the last coordinate clause.

In a word, "one of them" needs a "and" preceding it.

我笨，我努力

我的理解：

是同位语。因为one有指不清的问题，必须加上限定 one  of  the prosenters，用whom 来代替 prosenters

hanson_luo

如果one of whom是定语从句，为什么不紧跟着先行词presenters?限制性定语从句不是应该紧跟着先行词的嘛？

hpp920

投 JerryGuan 一票.

名词+形容词是可以做同位语的.

泰格尔

以下是引用JerryGuan在2004-6-6 22:15:00的发言：
我认为：one of whom 是 非限定性定语从句

同意是非限定性定从！

但我没搞清的是为何不是“one of who”?为什么这是里要用宾格而非主格呢？不论在主句还是从句中presenters都是作主语。

如何解释呢？谢谢！