再问大全304?

wycg

For many people, household labor remains demanding even if able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle.

(A) even if able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle

(B) despite being able to afford household appliances their grandparents would find a miracle

(C) even if they can afford household appliances their grandparents would have found miraculous

(D) although they could afford household appliances their grandparents would find miraculous（C）

(E) even if they are able to afford household appliances which would have been a miracle to their grandparents

请NN给讲讲C中最后用would have found有什么理由吗?谢谢!

carolhide

大全注释上讲了！

wycg

我看到了.

304, sec03-10

A) able to afford少主语, 会产生household labor is able to afford; their grandparents would find household appliances a miracle这样household appliances成了a miracle意思表达很awkward; 且would find语气不好。
B) despite不能表达复杂的意思和结构。
C) best. 用虚拟their grandparents would have found household appliances miraculous, 大意：(在过去)他们的祖父母会发现这些家用器具是奇迹。因为是虚拟, 故这种情况是不存在的, 说明household appliances对于their grandparents是新产物/本身就是个新事物, 不是个出现在过去的事物。
D) could和C中的can都表一种可能性, 感觉这时although(尽管), 从意思表达上不如even if(即使)好; would find表将来的一种语气, 这样会让人觉得household appliances是个还未问世的新产品, 意思与原意不符。
E) 1)household appliances和 a miracle单复数不对应, 意思awkward; 2)can afford本来是固定用法, be able to --- ability和afford --- ability, 二者都是种能力, 故it is redundant to use both; 3) which不好, Gmat中which通常修饰非限制性定从(前有逗号)，或者前有个介词。

那个would have 和would 只是在时间上有差别吗?另外even if 和although感觉上差别不大呀?

carolhide

以下是引用wycg在2006-1-15 11:39:00的发言：

我看到了.

304, sec03-10

A) able to afford少主语, 会产生household labor is able to afford; their grandparents would find household appliances a miracle这样household appliances成了a miracle意思表达很awkward; 且would find语气不好。
B) despite不能表达复杂的意思和结构。
C) best. 用虚拟their grandparents would have found household appliances miraculous, 大意：(在过去)他们的祖父母会发现这些家用器具是奇迹。因为是虚拟, 故这种情况是不存在的, 说明household appliances对于their grandparents是新产物/本身就是个新事物, 不是个出现在过去的事物。
D) could和C中的can都表一种可能性, 感觉这时although(尽管), 从意思表达上不如even if(即使)好; would find表将来的一种语气, 这样会让人觉得household appliances是个还未问世的新产品, 意思与原意不符。
E) 1)household appliances和 a miracle单复数不对应, 意思awkward; 2)can afford本来是固定用法, be able to --- ability和afford --- ability, 二者都是种能力, 故it is redundant to use both; 3) which不好, Gmat中which通常修饰非限制性定从(前有逗号)，或者前有个介词。

那个would have 和would 只是在时间上有差别吗?另外even if 和although感觉上差别不大呀?

当让步分句指一种臆想的情况时，通常不用although。

ly365

Families should be able to afford college, high school curriculum should be strengthened, and the government should give more money to educational institutions

bmwedward

Ding